Benchmark problems for physics-informed neural networks: The Allen–Cahn equation

Hyun Geun Lee; Youngjin Hwang; Yunjae Nam; Sangkwon Kim; Junseok Kim; Hyun Geun Lee; Youngjin Hwang; Yunjae Nam; Sangkwon Kim; Junseok Kim

doi:10.3934/math.2025335

AIMS Mathematics

2025, Volume 10, Issue 3: 7319-7338. doi: 10.3934/math.2025335

Previous Article Next Article

Research article Special Issues

Benchmark problems for physics-informed neural networks: The Allen–Cahn equation

1.
Department of Mathematics, Dongguk University, Seoul 04620, Republic of Korea
2.
Department of Mathematics, Korea University, Seoul 02841, Republic of Korea
3.
Program in Actuarial Science and Financial Engineering, Korea University, Seoul 02841, Republic of Korea

Received: 31 December 2024 Revised: 06 March 2025 Accepted: 26 March 2025 Published: 28 March 2025
MSC : 35K57, 65M22, 82C26

In this paper, we present accurate and well-designed benchmark problems for evaluating the effectiveness and precision of physics-informed neural networks (PINNs). The presented problems were generated using the Allen–Cahn (AC) equation, which models the mechanism of phase separation in binary alloy systems and simulates the temporal evolution of interfaces. The AC equation possesses the property of motion by mean curvature, which means that, in the sharp interface limit, the evolution of the interface described by the equation is governed by its mean curvature. Specifically, the velocity of the interface is proportional to its mean curvature, which implies the tendency of the interface to minimize its surface area. This property makes the AC equation a powerful mathematical model for capturing the dynamics of interface motion and phase separation processes in various physical and biological systems. The benchmark source codes for the 1D, 2D, and 3D AC equations are provided for interested researchers.

Keywords:

Citation: Hyun Geun Lee, Youngjin Hwang, Yunjae Nam, Sangkwon Kim, Junseok Kim. Benchmark problems for physics-informed neural networks: The Allen–Cahn equation[J]. AIMS Mathematics, 2025, 10(3): 7319-7338. doi: 10.3934/math.2025335

Related Papers:

[1]	Mashail M. Al Sobhi . The modified Kies-Fréchet distribution: Properties, inference and application. AIMS Mathematics, 2021, 6(5): 4691-4714. doi: 10.3934/math.2021276
[2]	M. G. M. Ghazal, Yusra A. Tashkandy, Oluwafemi Samson Balogun, M. E. Bakr . Exponentiated extended extreme value distribution: Properties, estimation, and applications in applied fields. AIMS Mathematics, 2024, 9(7): 17634-17656. doi: 10.3934/math.2024857
[3]	Dawlah Alsulami . A new extension of the Rayleigh distribution: Properties, different methods of estimation, and an application to medical data. AIMS Mathematics, 2025, 10(4): 7636-7663. doi: 10.3934/math.2025350
[4]	Ahmed Sedky Eldeeb, Muhammad Ahsan-ul-Haq, Mohamed S. Eliwa . A discrete Ramos-Louzada distribution for asymmetric and over-dispersed data with leptokurtic-shaped: Properties and various estimation techniques with inference. AIMS Mathematics, 2022, 7(2): 1726-1741. doi: 10.3934/math.2022099
[5]	Fiaz Ahmad Bhatti, Azeem Ali, G. G. Hamedani, Mustafa Ç. Korkmaz, Munir Ahmad . The unit generalized log Burr XII distribution: properties and application. AIMS Mathematics, 2021, 6(9): 10222-10252. doi: 10.3934/math.2021592
[6]	Naif Alotaibi, A. S. Al-Moisheer, Ibrahim Elbatal, Salem A. Alyami, Ahmed M. Gemeay, Ehab M. Almetwally . Bivariate step-stress accelerated life test for a new three-parameter model under progressive censored schemes with application in medical. AIMS Mathematics, 2024, 9(2): 3521-3558. doi: 10.3934/math.2024173
[7]	Khaled M. Alqahtani, Mahmoud El-Morshedy, Hend S. Shahen, Mohamed S. Eliwa . A discrete extension of the Burr-Hatke distribution: Generalized hypergeometric functions, different inference techniques, simulation ranking with modeling and analysis of sustainable count data. AIMS Mathematics, 2024, 9(4): 9394-9418. doi: 10.3934/math.2024458
[8]	Ayed. R. A. Alanzi, Muhammad Imran, M. H. Tahir, Christophe Chesneau, Farrukh Jamal, Saima Shakoor, Waqas Sami . Simulation analysis, properties and applications on a new Burr XII model based on the Bell-X functionalities. AIMS Mathematics, 2023, 8(3): 6970-7004. doi: 10.3934/math.2023352
[9]	Nuran M. Hassan, M. Nagy, Subhankar Dutta . Statistical inference for the bathtub-shaped distribution using balanced and unbalanced sampling techniques. AIMS Mathematics, 2024, 9(9): 25049-25069. doi: 10.3934/math.20241221
[10]	SidAhmed Benchiha, Amer Ibrahim Al-Omari, Naif Alotaibi, Mansour Shrahili . Weighted generalized Quasi Lindley distribution: Different methods of estimation, applications for Covid-19 and engineering data. AIMS Mathematics, 2021, 6(11): 11850-11878. doi: 10.3934/math.2021688

Abstract

1. Introduction

Data analysis has been received a great interest in several applied fields such as medicine, reliability analysis, engineering, environmental studies, and economics. Several authors have proposed more flexible statistical distributions to model and predict various experimental and phenomenal data encountered in applied fields.

The Fréchet (Fr) distribution is also known as the inverse-Weibull distribution and it is one of the useful distributions in extreme value theory. The Fr model has some important applications in life testing, floods, earthquakes, and wind speeds, among others. Further information about the applications of the Fr distribution can be explored in ^[1,2,3,4,5].

The Fr distribution is specified by the following cumulative distribution function (CDF)

$\begin{equation} F(x;\theta, \lambda) = e^{-\lambda x^{-\theta}}, \quad \quad \theta, \lambda > 0, \quad \quad x > 0. \end{equation}$

(1.1)

Its probability density function (PDF) reduces to

$\begin{equation} f(x;\theta, \lambda) = \theta\, \lambda\, {x}^{-(\theta+1)}e^{-\lambda{x}^{-\theta}}, \quad \quad \theta, \lambda > 0, \quad \quad x > 0, \end{equation}$

(1.2)

where $\theta$ and $\lambda$ are, respectively, the shape and scale parameters. The PDF (1.2) exhibits a unimodal shape or a decreasing shape depending on $\theta$ while its hazard rate function (HRF) is always unimodal.

There is a clear need to define and develop more flexible versions of the Fr model using the well-known families to model several datasets encountered in many applied fields such as medicine, geology, engineering, and economics, among others. Hence, many authors have proposed several generalized forms of the Fr distribution to improve its flexibility and capability in modeling real-life data. Some notable extensions are the following: the exponentiated-Fr ^[6], beta-Fr ^[7], Marshall–Olkin Fr ^[8], transmuted Marshall–Olkin Fr ^[9], Weibull–Fr ^[10], beta exponential-Fr ^[11], Burr-X Fr ^[12], odd Lindley–Fr ^[13], logarithmic-transformed Fr ^[14], and modified Kies–Fr distributions ^[15].

This article introduces a new flexible extension of the Fr distribution called the extended Weibull–Fréchet (EWFr) distribution, which provides more flexibility to model real-life data than other competing distributions. Then, the first motivation to this article is devoted to introducing the EWFr distribution as a new extension of the Fr distribution via the extended Weibull-G (EW-G) family ^[16]. The useful characteristics of the EWFr distribution can be summarized as follows: The EWFr distribution is a more flexible version for the Fr distribution, and it improves the fitting of real-life data; it produces more flexible kurtosis than the baseline Fr model. The HRF of the EWFr distribution can exhibit an upside-down bathtub shape, an increasing shape, and a decreasing shape. Its density function can exhibit a symmetrical shape, a unimodal shape, an asymmetrical shape, a J shape, and a reversed-J shape. Furthermore, the EWFr distribution can be adopted to model various data in the medicine and engineering sciences. This fact was illustrated by modeling two real datasets from both fields, showing its superiority fit over other competing distributions.

Another motivation to this article is to show how several classical estimators of the EWFr distribution perform for different parameter combinations and several sample sizes. Hence, the EWFr parameters are estimated using different estimation approaches including: the maximum product of spacings estimators (MPSEs), least-squares estimators (LSEs), the right-tail Anderson-Darling estimators (RADEs), the maximum likelihood estimators (MLEs), the weighted least-squares estimators (WLSEs), the percentiles estimators (PCEs), the Cramér–von Mises estimators (CRVMEs), and the Anderson–Darling estimators (ADEs). Extensive simulation results were introduced to explore the performance of these estimators. Furthermore, these estimators are compared using partial and overall ranks to determine the best method for estimation the parameters of the EWFr distribution.

The paper is organized in six sections as follows: Section 2 introduces the EWFr distribution and its related functions. The distribution properties are determined in Section 3. Section 4 presents some classical estimators of the EWFr parameters. The simulation results for the classical methods are provided in the same section. Two real-life datasets are fitted using the EWFr distribution in Section 5. Some final remarks are presented in Section 6.

2. The EWFr distribution

The EWFr distribution is constructed based on the EW-G family ^[16] which is specified, for any baseline CDF $G(x; \mathit{\boldsymbol{\zeta}})$ , by the CDF

$\begin{equation} F(x;\, \vartheta , \varphi , \mathit{\boldsymbol{\zeta}} ) = 1-\left\{1+\varphi {\left[\frac{G(x;\, \mathit{\boldsymbol{\zeta}})}{1-G(x;\, \mathit{\boldsymbol{\zeta}})}\right]}^\vartheta\right\}^{\frac{-1}{\varphi}}, \quad \quad \vartheta, \varphi > 0, \quad \quad x\in\Re. \end{equation}$

(2.1)

The corresponding PDF of (2.1) takes the form

$\begin{equation} f(x;\, \vartheta , \varphi , \mathit{\boldsymbol{\zeta}} ) = \frac{\vartheta \, g(x;\, \mathit{\boldsymbol{\zeta}})\, \, G(x;\, \mathit{\boldsymbol{\zeta}})^{\vartheta-1}}{ \left[1-G(x;\, \mathit{\boldsymbol{\zeta}})\right]^{\vartheta+1}} \left\{1+\varphi {\left[\frac{G(x;\, \mathit{\boldsymbol{\zeta}})}{1-G(x;\, \mathit{\boldsymbol{\zeta}})}\right]}^\vartheta\right\}^{\frac{-1}{\varphi}-1}. \end{equation}$

(2.2)

where $g(x; \mathit{\boldsymbol{\zeta}}) = d\, G(x; \mathit{\boldsymbol{\zeta}})/dx$ refers to the baseline density with parameter vector $\mathit{\boldsymbol{\zeta}}$ .

To this end, by inserting Eq (1.1) in (2.1), the CDF of the EWFr model follows as

$\begin{equation} F(x;\, \mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}}) = 1-\left\{1+{\varphi{\left(e^{\lambda{x}^{-\theta}}-1\right)^{-\vartheta}}}\right\}^{-\frac{1}{\varphi}}, \quad \quad \vartheta, \, \varphi, \, \lambda, \, \theta\, > 0, \quad \quad x > 0, \end{equation}$

(2.3)

where $\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}} = (\vartheta, \varphi, \lambda, \theta)^{\intercal}$ . The PDF of the EWFr model reduces to

$\begin{equation} f(x;\, \mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}}) = \vartheta\, \theta \, \lambda \, x^{-(\theta+1)}e^{\lambda{x}^{-\theta}} \left(e^{\lambda{x}^{-\theta}}-1\right)^{-(\vartheta+1)} \left\{1+{\varphi{\left(e^{\lambda{x}^{-\theta}}-1\right)^{-\vartheta}}}\right\}^{-(\frac{1}{\varphi}+1)}, \end{equation}$

(2.4)

where $\vartheta, \, \varphi$ and $\theta$ are shape parameters whereas $\lambda$ is a scale parameter.

2.1. Some Useful Functions and Shapes

The survival function (SF) of the EWFr distribution is given as

$\begin{equation} \label{EOWFrsfx} S(x;\, \mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}}) = \left\{1+{\varphi{\left(e^{\lambda{x}^{-\theta}}-1\right)^{-\vartheta}}}\right\}^{-\frac{1}{\varphi}}. \notag \end{equation}$

Long-term SF (LT-SF) is a useful feature in the modeling process, because a portion of the population may no longer be eligible to the event of interest with probability $p$ (see ^[17,18]).

The general form of the LT-SF is $S_{LT}(x; p, \mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}}) = p+(1-p)S(x; \mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}})$ , where $S(x; \mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}})$ denotes the SF of any distribution and $p$ denotes the probability of being cured. Hence, the PDF of the LT-SF can be derived as

$\begin{equation} \label{L_pdf} f_{LT}(x;p, \mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}}) = - \frac{\partial}{\partial{x}}S_{LT}(x;p, \mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}}) = (1-p)f(x;p, \mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}}), p\in(0, 1). \notag \end{equation}$

Using Eq (2.4), the PDF of the LT-SF of the EWFr distribution takes the form

$\begin{equation} \label{LEWFrPDF} f_{LT}(x;\, p, \mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}}) = \frac{\vartheta \theta \lambda (1-p)e^{\lambda{x}^{-\theta}}}{x^{\theta+1}} \left(e^{\lambda{x}^{-\theta}}-1\right)^{-(\vartheta+1)} \left\{1+{\varphi{\left(e^{\lambda{x}^{-\theta}}-1\right)^{-\vartheta}}}\right\}^{-(\frac{1}{\varphi}+1)}.\notag \end{equation}$

The HRF of the EWFr distribution takes the form

$\begin{equation} \label{EWFrHFR} h(x;\, \mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}}) = \frac{\vartheta \, \theta \, \lambda \, x^{-(\theta+1)}\, e^{\lambda{x}^{-\theta}}\, \left(e^{\lambda{x}^{-\theta}}-1\right)^{-(\vartheta+1)}} {1+{\varphi{\left(e^{\lambda{x}^{-\theta}}-1\right)^{-\vartheta}}}}.\notag \end{equation}$

Its reversed HRF has the form

$\begin{equation} \label{EWFrreversed} r(x;\, \mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}}) = \frac{\vartheta \, \theta \, \lambda \, x^{-(\theta+1)}e^{\lambda{x}^{-\theta}}\left(e^{\lambda{x}^{-\theta}}-1\right)^{-(\vartheta+1)} \left\{1+{\varphi{\left(e^{\lambda{x}^{-\theta}}-1\right)^{-\vartheta}}}\right\}^{-(\frac{1}{\varphi}+1)}} {1-\left\{1+{\varphi{\left(e^{\lambda{x}^{-\theta}}-1\right)^{-\vartheta}}}\right\}^{-\frac{1}{\varphi}}}.\notag \end{equation}$

The odd ratio of the EWFr model is derived as

$\begin{equation} \label{EWFrodds} O(x;\, \mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}}) = \frac{F(x|\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}})}{S(x|\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}})} = {\left\{1+{\varphi{\left(e^{\lambda{x}^{-\theta}}-1\right)^{-\vartheta}}}\right\}^{\frac{1}{\varphi}}}-1. \notag \end{equation}$

Figure 1 presents some possible shapes of the EWFr PDF for different values of its parameters. The EWFr PDF can be a symmetrical shape, a unimodal shape, an asymmetrical shape, a J shape, and a reversed-J shape. The hazard rate plots of the EWFr model are depicted in Figure 2. The EWFr HRF can be an increasing shape, a unimodal shape, and a decreasing shape.

Figure 1. Possible shapes of the EWFr PDF for several values of

$\vartheta$ ,

$\varphi$ ,

$\lambda$ and

$\theta$ .

DownLoad: Full-Size Img PowerPoint

Figure 2. Possible shapes of the EWFr HRF for several values of

$\vartheta$ ,

$\varphi$ ,

$\lambda$ and

$\theta$ .

DownLoad: Full-Size Img PowerPoint

3. The EWFr characteristics

3.1. Quantile function and median

The quantile function (QF) of the EWFr distribution, say, $Q(u)$ , can be calculated by solving $F(x) = p$ in (2.3) in terms of $p$ . Then, the EWFr QF follows as

$\begin{equation} Q(p) = \lambda^{\frac{1}{\theta}}\left\{\ln\left({\frac{\left[(1-p)^{-\varphi}-1\right]^{\frac{1}{\vartheta}}} {\varphi^{\frac{1}{\vartheta}}+\left[(1-p)^{-\varphi}-1\right]^{\frac{1}{\vartheta}}}}\right)\right\}^{\frac{1}{\theta}}, 0 < p < 1. \end{equation}$

(3.1)

The median of the EWFr distribution follows by substituting $p = 0.5$ in Eq (3.1).

3.2. Linear representation

A useful linear representation for the PDF of the EWFr model is provided based on ^[16]. Alizadeh et al. ^[16] introduced a simple representation for the density of the EW-G class as follows

$\begin{equation} f(x) = \sum\limits_{w, u = 0}^{\infty}\psi_{w, u}\, h_{{\vartheta}w+u}(x), \end{equation}$

(3.2)

where $\psi_{w, u} = -\varphi^{w}\, \Gamma({\vartheta}w+u)\, (-\frac{1}{\varphi})_{w}/ [\, w!\, \, \, u! \, \Gamma({\vartheta}w)]$ and

$\begin{equation*} h_{\vartheta\, w+u}(x) = (\vartheta\, w+u)\, \, g(x)\, \, G(x)^{\vartheta\, w+u-1}, \end{equation*}$

is the exponentiated-G PDF with a power parameter $(\vartheta\, w+u) > 0$ . Using Eqs (1.1) and (1.2) of the Fr distribution, Eq (3.2) can be expressed as

$\begin{equation} f(x) = \sum\limits_{w, u = 0}^{\infty}\psi_{w, u}\, (\vartheta\, w+u)\, \theta \, \lambda\, x^{-(\theta+1)}\, e^{-{(\vartheta\, w+u)\, \lambda}\, x^{-\theta}}. \end{equation}$

(3.3)

Equation (3.3) can be rewritten as

$\begin{equation} f(x) = \sum\limits_{w, u = 0}^{\infty}\psi_{w, u} \, \, g_{({\vartheta}w+u)}(x), \end{equation}$

(3.4)

where $g_{({\vartheta}w+u)}(x)$ denotes the Fr PDF with two-parameter $\theta$ and $({\vartheta}w+u)\lambda$ . Then, the density function of the EWFr model is expressed as a linear representation of Fr densities. Let $Y$ be a random variable having the Fr distribution in (1.1). Hence, the $r-$ th ordinary, $\mu^\prime_{r, Y}$ , and incomplete moments, $\phi_{(r, Y)}(t)$ , of $Y$ are, respectively, given (for $r < \lambda$ , ) by

$\begin{equation*} \mu^\prime_{r, Y} = \lambda^{\frac{r}{\theta}}\, \Gamma(1-\frac{r}{\theta})\quad \text{and} \quad \phi_{(r, Y)}(t) = \lambda^{\frac{r}{\theta}}\gamma(1-\frac{r}{\theta}, \lambda t^{-\theta}), \end{equation*}$

where $\Gamma(s) = \int_{0}^{\infty}w^{s-1}\, e^{-w} \, dw$ is the complete gamma function (GF) and $\gamma(s, z) = \int_{0}^{z}w^{s-1}\, e^{-w}\, dw$ is the lower incomplete GF.

3.3. Moments and incomplete moments

This section was devoted to deriving the $r-$ th ordinary moment and incomplete moments of the EWFr distribution.

Proposition: Based on (3.4), the $r-$ th moment of the EWFr distribution is defined by

$\begin{equation*} \label{rmNM} \mu^\prime_r = \sum\limits_{w, u = 0}^{\infty}\psi_{w, u} \, \, \int_{0}^{\infty}x^r g_{\vartheta {w}+u}(x) dx \, \, \text{for} \quad r\in\mathbb{N}. \end{equation*}$

$\begin{equation} \mu^\prime_r = \sum\limits_{w, u = 0}^{\infty}\psi_{w, u} \, \, \left(\vartheta{w}+u\right)^{\frac{r}{\theta}}\, \, \Gamma\left(1-\frac{r}{\theta}\right). \end{equation}$

(3.5)

Setting $r = 1$ in Eq (3.5), we get the mean of $x$ .

The $s-$ th incomplete moment, say $\phi_{s}(x)$ , of the EWFr distribution takes the form

$\begin{equation*} \phi_{s}(t) = \int_{0}^{t} x^{s}\, \, f(x)\, \, dx = \sum\limits_{w, u = 0}^{\infty}\psi_{w, u}\, \, \int_{0}^{t} \, \, x^{s}\, \, g_{(\vartheta\, w+u)}(x)dx. \end{equation*}$

Then, we obtain $(for s < \theta)$

$\begin{equation} \label{incomplete_final} \phi_{s}(t) = \sum\limits_{w, u = 0}^{\infty} \psi_{w, u}\, \, (\vartheta\, w+u)^{\frac{s}{\theta}}\, \, \gamma\left(1-\frac{s}{\theta}, \, (\vartheta\, w+u){\lambda} \, t^{-\theta}\right).\notag \end{equation}$

The mean ( $\mu$ ), variance ( $\sigma^{2}$ ), skewness ( $\xi_{1}(X)$ ), and kurtosis ( $\xi _{2}(X)$ ) of the EWFr distribution are calculated numerically with $\lambda = 1$ and different values of $\vartheta$ , $\varphi$ and $\theta$ . displays these numerical results. shows that the EWFr model can be right-skewed and it can be leptokurtic (i.e., $\xi _{2}(X) > 3$ ).

Table 1. Some numerical values for

$\mu$ ,

$\sigma^{2}$ ,

$\xi_{1}(X)$ , and

$\xi_{2}(X)$ of the EWFr distribution with

$\lambda = 1$ and different values of

$\vartheta$ ,

$\varphi$ and

$\theta$ .

$\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}}^{\intercal}$	$\mu$	$\sigma^{2}$	$\xi_{1}(X)$	$\xi_{2}(X)$
$(\vartheta=1.50, \; \varphi=0.50, \; \theta=1.50)$	1.3511	0.4752	3.1421	56.2021
$(\vartheta=2.50, \; \varphi=0.75, \; \theta=1.75)$	1.2701	0.1329	1.9395	16.1410
$(\vartheta=2.25, \; \varphi=1.00, \; \theta=2.75)$	1.1904	0.0780	2.2648	19.2907
$(\vartheta=2.25, \; \varphi=0.25, \; \theta=0.75)$	1.6154	0.7600	1.6132	9.0569
$(\vartheta=2.25, \; \varphi=1.25, \; \theta=3.25)$	1.1831	0.0747	2.8068	27.8064
$(\vartheta=5.50, \; \varphi=1.50, \; \theta=2.50)$	1.1927	0.0223	1.7507	11.7806

| Show Table

DownLoad: CSV

3.4. Order statistics

Let $X_{1}, \, X_{2}, \, \dots \, X_{n}$ be a random sample from the EWFr (2.4) and $X_{1:n}\leq X_{2:n}\leq\dots\leq X_{n:n}$ be their corresponding order statistics (OS). The PDF and the CDF of the of $r-$ th OS, say, $X_{r:n}$ and $1\leq r \leq n$ are, respectively, defined by

$\begin{equation} \begin{aligned} f_{r:n}(x)& = \frac{n!}{(n-r)!\, (r-1)!}\, [F(x)]^{r-1}\, \, [1-F(x)]^{n-r}\, \, f(x) \\ & = \frac{n!}{(n-r)!\, (r-1)!}\sum\limits_{u = 0}^{n-r}(-1)^{u}\left(\begin{array}{c}n-r\\u\end{array}\right)\, \, [F(x)]^{r-1+u}\, \, f(x) \end{aligned} \end{equation}$

(3.6)

and (for $k = 1, 2, \dots, n$ )

$\begin{equation} \begin{aligned} F_{r:n}(x) = \sum\limits_{l = k}^{n}\left(\begin{array}{c}n\\l\end{array}\right)\, \, [F(x)]^{l}\, \, [1-F(x)]^{n-l} = \sum\limits_{l = k}^{n}\sum\limits_{u = 0}^{n-r}(-1)^{u}\, \, \left(\begin{array}{c}n\\l\end{array}\right) \left(\begin{array}{c}n-r\\u\end{array}\right)\, \, [F(x)]^{l+u}. \end{aligned} \end{equation}$

(3.7)

Using Eqs (3.6) and (3.7), the PDF and CDF of the $r-$ th OS of the EWFr reduce to

$\begin{equation*} \begin{aligned} f_{r:n}(x) = &\frac{\vartheta\; \theta\; \lambda \; x^{-(\theta+1)\; n!}}{(r-1)!(n-r)!}e^{\lambda{t}^{-\theta}} \left(e^{\lambda{x}^{-\theta}}-1\right)^{-(\vartheta+1)} \left\{1+{\varphi{\left(e^{\lambda{x}^{-\theta}}-1\right)^{-\vartheta}}}\right\}^{-(\frac{1}{\varphi}+1)} \\ & \sum\limits_{u = 0}^{n-r}(-1)^{u}\left(\begin{array}{c}n-r\\u\end{array}\right) \left[1-\left\{1+{\varphi{\left(e^{\lambda{x}^{-\theta}}-1\right)^{-\vartheta}}}\right\}^{-\frac{1}{\varphi}}\right]^{r+u-1} \end{aligned} \end{equation*}$

and

$\begin{equation*} F_{r:n}(x) = \sum\limits_{l = k}^{n}\sum\limits_{u = 0}^{n-r}(-1)^{u}\left(\begin{array}{c}n\\l\end{array}\right)\left(\begin{array}{c}n-r\\u\end{array}\right) \left[1-\left\{1+{\varphi{\left(e^{\lambda{x}^{-\theta}}-1\right)^{-\vartheta}}}\right\}^{-\frac{1}{\varphi}}\right]^{l+u}. \end{equation*}$

4. Estimation and simulations

In this section, the EWFr parameters $\vartheta$ , $\lambda$ , $\varphi$ and $\theta$ are estimated using different frequentist approaches. We also provide detailed simulation results to compare and order their performances using partial and overall ranks.

4.1. Maximum likelihood estimators

The MLEs of the parameters $\vartheta$ , $\lambda$ , $\varphi$ and $\theta$ of the EWFr distribution are introduced in this sub-section. Let $x_1, \dots, x_n$ be a sample from the EWFr distribution in (2.4). Hence, the log-likelihood function of $\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}} = (\vartheta, \varphi, \lambda, \theta)^{\intercal}$ takes the form

$\begin{equation} \label{logMLE} \begin{aligned} l(\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}};\mathit{\boldsymbol{x}}) = n\log\left(\vartheta\right)&+ n\log\left(\theta\right)+n\log\left(\lambda\right)-(\theta+1)\sum\limits_{i = 1}^{n}\log(x_{i})-(\vartheta+1)\sum\limits_{i = 1}^{n}\log\left(e^{\lambda{x_{i}}^{-\theta}}-1\right)&& \notag\\ &+\lambda\sum\limits_{i = 1}^{n}{x_{i}}^{-\theta}-(\frac{1}{\varphi}+1)\sum\limits_{i = 1}^{n}\log\left\{1+\varphi\left(e^{\lambda{x_{i}}^{-\theta}}-1\right)^{-\vartheta}\right\}.&& \end{aligned} \end{equation}$

The MLEs follow by maximizing the above equation by several programs such as {SAS} ({PROC NLMIXED}) or {R} ({optim} function).

4.2. Ordinary and weighted least-squares estimators

Let $x_{(1)}$ , $x_{(2)}$ , $\cdots$ , $x_{(n)}$ be the OS of a random sample from the PDF (2.4), then the LSEs ^[19] of the EWFr parameters are obtained by minimizing the function:

$\begin{equation*} S(\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}}) = \sum\limits_{i = 1}^{n}\left[F(x_{(i)})-\frac{i}{n+1}\right]^{2}. \end{equation*}$

Similarly, these estimators are also obtained by solving the following equation (for $k = 1, 2, 3, 4$ )

$\begin{equation*} \sum\limits_{i = 1}^{n}\left(\left\{1+\varphi\left(e^{\lambda{x_{i}}^{-\theta}}-1\right)^{-\vartheta}\right\}^{-\frac{1}{\varphi}} -\frac{i}{n+1}\right)\Omega _{k}\left( x_{(i)}|\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}} \right) = 0, \\ \end{equation*}$

where

$\begin{equation} \label{LSEs1} \Omega _{1}\left( x_{(i)}|\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}} \right) = \frac{\partial }{\partial \vartheta }F\left(x_{(i)}|\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}} \right) = \quad\frac{1}{\varphi}\left(1+{\varphi{w_{i}^{-\vartheta}}}\right)^{-(\frac{1}{\varphi}+1)}-{\varphi} w_{i}^{-\vartheta} \ln{w_{i}}, \notag \end{equation}$

$\begin{equation} \label{LSEs2} \Omega_{2}\left( x_{(i)}|\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}} \right) = \frac{\partial }{\partial\varphi }F\left( x_{(i)}|\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}} \right) = \quad\left(1+{\varphi{w_{i}^{-\vartheta}}}\right)^{-\frac{1}{\varphi}}\ln{\left(1+{\varphi{w_{i}^{-\vartheta}}}\right)}, \notag \end{equation}$

$\begin{equation} \label{LSEs3} \Omega_{3}\left( x_{(i)}|\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}} \right) = \frac{\partial }{\partial\lambda }F\left( x_{(i)}|\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}} \right) = \quad\frac{1}{\varphi}\left(1+{\varphi{w_{i}^{-\vartheta}}}\right)^{-(\frac{1}{\varphi}+1)} -\vartheta\varphi{x_{i}^{-\theta}}{w_{i}^{-(\vartheta+1)}}e^{\lambda{x_{i}}^{-\theta}}\notag \end{equation}$

and

$\begin{equation} \label{LSEs4} \Omega_{4}\left( x_{(i)}|\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}} \right) = \frac{\partial }{\partial\theta }F\left( x_{(i)}|\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}} \right) = \quad\vartheta\lambda{w_{i}^{-(\vartheta+1)}}e^{\lambda{x_{i}}^{-\theta}}{x_{i}^{-\theta}} \left(1+{\varphi{w_{i}^{-\vartheta}}}\right)^{-(\frac{1}{\varphi}+1)}\ln{x_{i}}, \notag \end{equation}$

where $w_{i} = e^{\lambda{x_{i}}^{-\theta}}-1$ . The solution of $\Omega _{k}$ for $k = 1, 2, 3, 4$ may be obtained numerically.

The WLSEs of the EWFr parameters can be determined by minimizing the equation (see ^[19]):

$\begin{equation*} W\left(\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}} \right) = \sum\limits_{i = 1}^{n}\frac{\left( n+1\right) ^{2}\left( n+2\right) }{i\left( n-i+1\right) }\left[ F\left( x_{(i)}|\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}} \right) -\frac{i}{n+1}\right]^{2}. \end{equation*}$

4.3. Maximum product of spacing and Cramér–von Mises estimators

The uniform spacings of a random sample from the EWFr distribution are defined (for $i = 1, 2, \dots, n+1$ ) by { $D_{i}(\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}}) = F\left(x_{(i)}|\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}} \right) -F\left(x_{(i-1)}|\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}}\right)$ }, where $F\left(x_{(0)}|\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}} \right) = 0$ , $F\left(x_{(n+1)}|\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}} \right) = 1$ and $\sum_{i = 1}^{n+1}D_{i}(\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}}) = 1$ . The MPSEs of the EWFr parameters can be determined by maximizing the following geometric mean (GM) of spacings

$\begin{equation*} G\left(\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}} \right) = \left[ \prod\limits_{i = 1}^{n+1}D_{i}( \mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}} )\right] ^{\frac{1}{n+1}} \end{equation*}$

or by maximizing the logarithm of the GM of sample spacings

$\begin{equation*} H\left(\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}} \right) = \frac{1}{n+1}\sum\limits_{i = 1}^{n+1}\log D_{i}(\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}}), \end{equation*}$

The CRVMEs can be obtained using the difference between the estimated and empirical CDFs. The CRVMEs ^[20] of the EWFr parameters are determined by minimizing

$\begin{equation*} C(\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}}) = \frac{1}{12n}+\sum\limits_{i = 1}^{n}\left[ F\left(x_{(i)}|\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}} \right) -{\frac{2i-1}{2n}}\right] ^{2}. \end{equation*}$

4.4. Anderson–Darling and right-tail Anderson–Darling estimators

The ADEs ^[21] of the EWFr parameters are calculated by minimizing

$\begin{equation*} A(\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}}) = -n-\frac{1}{n}\sum\limits_{i = 1}^{n}\left( 2i-1\right) \, \left[\log F\left( x_{(i)}|\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}} \right) +\log S\left( x_{(i)}|\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}} \right) \right]. \end{equation*}$

The RADEs of the EWFr parameters are calculated by minimizing

$\begin{equation*} R(\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}} ) = \frac{n}{2}-2\sum\limits_{i = 1}^{n}F\left( x_{i:n}|\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}} \right) -\frac{1}{n}\sum\limits_{i = 1}^{n}\left( 2i-1\right) \log S\left( x_{n+1-i:n}|\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}} \right). \end{equation*}$

4.5. Percentile estimators

Consider the unbiased estimator of $F\left(x_{(i)}|\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}} \right)$ which is defined by $u_{i} = i/\left(n+1\right)$ . Hence, the PCEs of the EWFr parameters can be calculated by minimizing

$\begin{equation*} P(\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}}) = \sum\limits_{i = 1}^{n}\left( x_{(i)}-\left\{\ln\left({\frac{\left[(1-u_{i})^{-\varphi}-1\right]^{\frac{1}{\vartheta}}}{\varphi^{\frac{1}{\vartheta}} +\left[(1-u_{i})^{-\varphi}-1\right]^{\frac{1}{\vartheta}}}}\right)^{\lambda}\right\}^{\frac{1}{\theta}} \right)^{2}. \end{equation*}$

4.6. Simulation analysis

To compare and explore the behavior of different estimators of the EWFr parameters, we presented the numerical simulation results and ranked them with respect to their: average of absolute biases ( $|Bias(\widehat{\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}}})|$ ), $|Bias(\widehat{\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}}})| =$ $\frac{1}{N}\sum_{i = 1}^{N}|\widehat{\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}}}-\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}}|$ , average of mean relative errors (MREs), $MREs = \frac{1}{N}\sum_{i = 1}^{N}|\widehat{\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}}}-\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}}|/\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}}$ , and average mean square errors (MSEs), $MSEs = \frac{1}{N}\sum_{i = 1}^{N}(\widehat{\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}}}-\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}})^2$ .

The following algorithm can be adopted to explore the behavior of different estimators of the EWFr parameters:

Step 1: A random sample $x_{1}, x_{2}, \dots, x_{n}$ of sizes $n = 20,$ $80,$ $200,$ and $500$ are generated from the QF (3.1).

Step 2: The required results are obtained based on eight combinations of the parameters $\vartheta = \{0.25, 0.75, 1.75, 3.50, 3.50\}$ , $\varphi = \{0.50, 0.75, 2.00, 2.50, 3.50\}$ , $\lambda = \{0.25, 0.50, 1.50, 3.00, 4.25\}$ and $\theta = \{0.25, 1.25, 2.50\}$ .

Step 3: Each sample is replicated $N = 5,000$ times.

Step 4: Results of the biases, MSEs, and MREs are computed for the eight combinations, and to save more space, we present just the result of 5 combinations in Tables 2–6.

Table 2. Simulation results for

$\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}} = (\vartheta = 1.75, \varphi = 0.5, \lambda = 0.25, \theta = 1.25)^{\intercal}$ .

$n$	Est.	Est. Par.	MLEs	LSEs	WLSEs	CRVMEs	MPSEs	PCEs	ADEs	RADEs
20	\|BIAS\|	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.58150 $^{\{3\}}$	0.59477 $^{\{4\}}$	0.53422 $^{\{1\}}$	0.54541 $^{\{2\}}$	0.60555 $^{\{5\}}$	0.71685 $^{\{8\}}$	0.67445 $^{\{7\}}$	0.61466 $^{\{6\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.47550 $^{\{4\}}$	0.54812 $^{\{7\}}$	0.46820 $^{\{2\}}$	0.53093 $^{\{6\}}$	0.19120 $^{\{1\}}$	0.55104 $^{\{8\}}$	0.46906 $^{\{3\}}$	0.51894 $^{\{5\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.08930 $^{\{2\}}$	0.10351 $^{\{7\}}$	0.08402 $^{\{1\}}$	0.10057 $^{\{5\}}$	0.10077 $^{\{6\}}$	0.11204 $^{\{8\}}$	0.09758 $^{\{3\}}$	0.09866 $^{\{4\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.49749 $^{\{7\}}$	0.47497 $^{\{4\}}$	0.46884 $^{\{3\}}$	0.48364 $^{\{5\}}$	0.45238 $^{\{1\}}$	0.53285 $^{\{8\}}$	0.46505 $^{\{2\}}$	0.48608 $^{\{6\}}$
	MSEs	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.47425 $^{\{2\}}$	0.52401 $^{\{4\}}$	0.52337 $^{\{3\}}$	0.46463 $^{\{1\}}$	0.54588 $^{\{6\}}$	0.64689 $^{\{8\}}$	0.59726 $^{\{7\}}$	0.53428 $^{\{5\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.27624 $^{\{1\}}$	0.38734 $^{\{7\}}$	0.29294 $^{\{2\}}$	0.36212 $^{\{6\}}$	0.31849 $^{\{4\}}$	0.39577 $^{\{8\}}$	0.30160 $^{\{3\}}$	0.35513 $^{\{5\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.01107 $^{\{2\}}$	0.01423 $^{\{7\}}$	0.00983 $^{\{1\}}$	0.01356 $^{\{5\}}$	0.01357 $^{\{6\}}$	0.01651 $^{\{8\}}$	0.01289 $^{\{3\}}$	0.01296 $^{\{4\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.37764 $^{\{7\}}$	0.33320 $^{\{3\}}$	0.35778 $^{\{4\}}$	0.36101 $^{\{5\}}$	0.29381 $^{\{1\}}$	0.38887 $^{\{8\}}$	0.32193 $^{\{2\}}$	0.36311 $^{\{6\}}$
	MREs	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.33229 $^{\{3\}}$	0.33987 $^{\{4\}}$	0.17807 $^{\{1\}}$	0.31166 $^{\{2\}}$	0.34603 $^{\{5\}}$	0.40963 $^{\{8\}}$	0.38540 $^{\{7\}}$	0.35123 $^{\{6\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.95101 $^{\{3\}}$	1.09624 $^{\{7\}}$	0.93641 $^{\{1\}}$	1.06186 $^{\{6\}}$	0.97231 $^{\{4\}}$	1.10208 $^{\{8\}}$	0.93811 $^{\{2\}}$	1.03788 $^{\{5\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.35719 $^{\{2\}}$	0.41405 $^{\{7\}}$	0.33607 $^{\{1\}}$	0.40230 $^{\{5\}}$	0.40307 $^{\{6\}}$	0.44817 $^{\{8\}}$	0.39034 $^{\{3\}}$	0.39464 $^{\{4\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.39799 $^{\{7\}}$	0.37998 $^{\{4\}}$	0.37507 $^{\{3\}}$	0.38691 $^{\{5\}}$	0.36190 $^{\{1\}}$	0.42628 $^{\{8\}}$	0.37204 $^{\{2\}}$	0.38886 $^{\{6\}}$
		$\sum{Ranks}$	43 $^{\{2\}}$	65 $^{\{7\}}$	23 $^{\{1\}}$	53 $^{\{5\}}$	46 $^{\{4\}}$	96 $^{\{8\}}$	44 $^{\{3\}}$	62 $^{\{6\}}$
80	\|BIAS\|	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.65720 $^{\{2\}}$	0.73260 $^{\{6\}}$	0.64523 $^{\{1\}}$	0.71780 $^{\{4\}}$	0.67014 $^{\{3\}}$	0.78730 $^{\{8\}}$	0.72979 $^{\{5\}}$	0.78285 $^{\{7\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.29918 $^{\{4\}}$	0.36951 $^{\{7\}}$	0.27270 $^{\{1\}}$	0.36572 $^{\{6\}}$	0.28461 $^{\{2\}}$	0.43485 $^{\{8\}}$	0.29440 $^{\{3\}}$	0.31911 $^{\{5\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.06946 $^{\{2\}}$	0.08089 $^{\{7\}}$	0.06755 $^{\{1\}}$	0.07955 $^{\{6\}}$	0.07162 $^{\{4\}}$	0.07099 $^{\{3\}}$	0.07301 $^{\{5\}}$	0.08347 $^{\{8\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.41705 $^{\{6\}}$	0.41605 $^{\{5\}}$	0.41277 $^{\{4\}}$	0.43216 $^{\{7\}}$	0.34179 $^{\{1\}}$	0.38656 $^{\{3\}}$	0.37952 $^{\{2\}}$	0.45183 $^{\{8\}}$
	MSEs	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.53699 $^{\{1\}}$	0.65792 $^{\{5\}}$	0.71214 $^{\{7\}}$	0.63722 $^{\{3\}}$	0.62257 $^{\{2\}}$	0.71659 $^{\{8\}}$	0.64185 $^{\{4\}}$	0.70948 $^{\{6\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.12478 $^{\{3\}}$	0.19502 $^{\{7\}}$	0.11097 $^{\{1\}}$	0.18881 $^{\{6\}}$	0.12320 $^{\{2\}}$	0.28084 $^{\{8\}}$	0.13150 $^{\{4\}}$	0.15268 $^{\{5\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.00672 $^{\{1\}}$	0.00884 $^{\{7\}}$	0.00693 $^{\{2\}}$	0.00853 $^{\{6\}}$	0.00712 $^{\{4\}}$	0.00711 $^{\{3\}}$	0.00740 $^{\{5\}}$	0.00932 $^{\{8\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.26049 $^{\{5\}}$	0.25434 $^{\{4\}}$	0.30456 $^{\{8\}}$	0.27845 $^{\{6\}}$	0.16695 $^{\{1\}}$	0.24032 $^{\{3\}}$	0.20942 $^{\{2\}}$	0.29980 $^{\{7\}}$
	MREs	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.37554 $^{\{2\}}$	0.41863 $^{\{6\}}$	0.21508 $^{\{1\}}$	0.41017 $^{\{4\}}$	0.38294 $^{\{3\}}$	0.44989 $^{\{8\}}$	0.41702 $^{\{5\}}$	0.44734 $^{\{7\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.59835 $^{\{4\}}$	0.73902 $^{\{7\}}$	0.54540 $^{\{1\}}$	0.73144 $^{\{6\}}$	0.56922 $^{\{2\}}$	0.86970 $^{\{8\}}$	0.58881 $^{\{3\}}$	0.63822 $^{\{5\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.27786 $^{\{2\}}$	0.32356 $^{\{7\}}$	0.27019 $^{\{1\}}$	0.31820 $^{\{6\}}$	0.28647 $^{\{4\}}$	0.28396 $^{\{3\}}$	0.29205 $^{\{5\}}$	0.33388 $^{\{8\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.33364 $^{\{6\}}$	0.33284 $^{\{5\}}$	0.33022 $^{\{4\}}$	0.34573 $^{\{7\}}$	0.27343 $^{\{1\}}$	0.30924 $^{\{3\}}$	0.30361 $^{\{2\}}$	0.36147 $^{\{8\}}$
		$\sum{Ranks}$	38 $^{\{3\}}$	73 $^{\{7\}}$	32 $^{\{2\}}$	67 $^{\{6\}}$	29 $^{\{1\}}$	66 $^{\{5\}}$	45 $^{\{4\}}$	82 $^{\{8\}}$
200	\|BIAS\|	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.54244 $^{\{1\}}$	0.74060 $^{\{6\}}$	0.66029 $^{\{4\}}$	0.72065 $^{\{5\}}$	0.56860 $^{\{2\}}$	0.78528 $^{\{8\}}$	0.64417 $^{\{3\}}$	0.74318 $^{\{7\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.20343 $^{\{3\}}$	0.27714 $^{\{7\}}$	0.18758 $^{\{1\}}$	0.27628 $^{\{6\}}$	0.19120 $^{\{2\}}$	0.33648 $^{\{8\}}$	0.21264 $^{\{4\}}$	0.21990 $^{\{5\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.05329 $^{\{1\}}$	0.07033 $^{\{7\}}$	0.05985 $^{\{3\}}$	0.06898 $^{\{6\}}$	0.05669 $^{\{2\}}$	0.05992 $^{\{4\}}$	0.06059 $^{\{5\}}$	0.07617 $^{\{8\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.30910 $^{\{2\}}$	0.38666 $^{\{6\}}$	0.37834 $^{\{5\}}$	0.39240 $^{\{7\}}$	0.26754 $^{\{1\}}$	0.34697 $^{\{4\}}$	0.32167 $^{\{3\}}$	0.42492 $^{\{8\}}$
	MSEs	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.39682 $^{\{1\}}$	0.65105 $^{\{6\}}$	0.72704 $^{\{8\}}$	0.62292 $^{\{4\}}$	0.51529 $^{\{2\}}$	0.70871 $^{\{7\}}$	0.53035 $^{\{3\}}$	0.65051 $^{\{5\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.06226 $^{\{3\}}$	0.11401 $^{\{7\}}$	0.05424 $^{\{1\}}$	0.11214 $^{\{6\}}$	0.05643 $^{\{2\}}$	0.18593 $^{\{8\}}$	0.06927 $^{\{4\}}$	0.07447 $^{\{5\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.00405 $^{\{1\}}$	0.00665 $^{\{7\}}$	0.00571 $^{\{5\}}$	0.00644 $^{\{6\}}$	0.00452 $^{\{2\}}$	0.00513 $^{\{4\}}$	0.00507 $^{\{3\}}$	0.00753 $^{\{8\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.14395 $^{\{2\}}$	0.20851 $^{\{5\}}$	0.26568 $^{\{8\}}$	0.22075 $^{\{6\}}$	0.10322 $^{\{1\}}$	0.19203 $^{\{4\}}$	0.14560 $^{\{3\}}$	0.25309 $^{\{7\}}$
	MREs	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.30997 $^{\{2\}}$	0.42320 $^{\{6\}}$	0.22010 $^{\{1\}}$	0.41180 $^{\{5\}}$	0.32491 $^{\{3\}}$	0.44873 $^{\{8\}}$	0.36810 $^{\{4\}}$	0.42468 $^{\{7\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.40685 $^{\{3\}}$	0.55429 $^{\{7\}}$	0.37516 $^{\{1\}}$	0.55256 $^{\{6\}}$	0.38240 $^{\{2\}}$	0.67295 $^{\{8\}}$	0.42528 $^{\{4\}}$	0.43980 $^{\{5\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.21316 $^{\{1\}}$	0.28134 $^{\{7\}}$	0.23940 $^{\{3\}}$	0.27593 $^{\{6\}}$	0.22675 $^{\{2\}}$	0.23969 $^{\{4\}}$	0.24238 $^{\{5\}}$	0.30470 $^{\{8\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.24728 $^{\{2\}}$	0.30933 $^{\{6\}}$	0.30267 $^{\{5\}}$	0.31392 $^{\{7\}}$	0.21403 $^{\{1\}}$	0.27758 $^{\{4\}}$	0.25734 $^{\{3\}}$	0.33994 $^{\{8\}}$
		$\sum{Ranks}$	22 $^{\{1.5\}}$	77 $^{\{7\}}$	45 $^{\{4\}}$	70 $^{\{5\}}$	22 $^{\{1.5\}}$	71 $^{\{6\}}$	44 $^{\{3\}}$	81 $^{\{8\}}$
500	\|BIAS\|	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.40816 $^{\{2\}}$	0.63822 $^{\{6\}}$	0.59712 $^{\{4\}}$	0.62303 $^{\{5\}}$	0.38723 $^{\{1\}}$	0.72351 $^{\{8\}}$	0.50869 $^{\{3\}}$	0.64537 $^{\{7\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.13392 $^{\{3\}}$	0.19775 $^{\{6\}}$	0.12778 $^{\{1\}}$	0.19966 $^{\{7\}}$	0.13208 $^{\{2\}}$	0.26446 $^{\{8\}}$	0.14927 $^{\{4\}}$	0.15660 $^{\{5\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.03902 $^{\{1\}}$	0.05985 $^{\{7\}}$	0.04987 $^{\{4\}}$	0.05913 $^{\{6\}}$	0.04014 $^{\{2\}}$	0.05408 $^{\{5\}}$	0.04806 $^{\{3\}}$	0.06618 $^{\{8\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.21255 $^{\{2\}}$	0.32416 $^{\{6\}}$	0.31285 $^{\{5\}}$	0.33146 $^{\{7\}}$	0.18308 $^{\{1\}}$	0.30762 $^{\{4\}}$	0.24975 $^{\{3\}}$	0.35803 $^{\{8\}}$
	MSEs	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.24842 $^{\{1\}}$	0.52025 $^{\{5\}}$	0.58302 $^{\{7\}}$	0.50041 $^{\{4\}}$	0.33081 $^{\{2\}}$	0.63280 $^{\{8\}}$	0.37071 $^{\{3\}}$	0.52827 $^{\{6\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.02762 $^{\{3\}}$	0.05937 $^{\{6\}}$	0.02573 $^{\{1\}}$	0.06052 $^{\{7\}}$	0.02727 $^{\{2\}}$	0.12045 $^{\{8\}}$	0.03399 $^{\{4\}}$	0.03724 $^{\{5\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.00224 $^{\{1\}}$	0.00478 $^{\{7\}}$	0.00422 $^{\{5\}}$	0.00470 $^{\{6\}}$	0.00257 $^{\{2\}}$	0.00402 $^{\{4\}}$	0.00325 $^{\{3\}}$	0.00569 $^{\{8\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.06777 $^{\{2\}}$	0.14391 $^{\{5\}}$	0.19157 $^{\{8\}}$	0.15413 $^{\{6\}}$	0.05743 $^{\{1\}}$	0.14128 $^{\{4\}}$	0.08776 $^{\{3\}}$	0.17743 $^{\{7\}}$
	MREs	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.23323 $^{\{3\}}$	0.36470 $^{\{6\}}$	0.19904 $^{\{1\}}$	0.35602 $^{\{5\}}$	0.22127 $^{\{2\}}$	0.41343 $^{\{8\}}$	0.29068 $^{\{4\}}$	0.36879 $^{\{7\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.26784 $^{\{3\}}$	0.39550 $^{\{6\}}$	0.25556 $^{\{1\}}$	0.39932 $^{\{7\}}$	0.26417 $^{\{2\}}$	0.52891 $^{\{8\}}$	0.29853 $^{\{4\}}$	0.31320 $^{\{5\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.15609 $^{\{1\}}$	0.23939 $^{\{7\}}$	0.19949 $^{\{4\}}$	0.23651 $^{\{6\}}$	0.16056 $^{\{2\}}$	0.21632 $^{\{5\}}$	0.19222 $^{\{3\}}$	0.26474 $^{\{8\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.17004 $^{\{2\}}$	0.25933 $^{\{6\}}$	0.25028 $^{\{5\}}$	0.26517 $^{\{7\}}$	0.14646 $^{\{1\}}$	0.24610 $^{\{4\}}$	0.19980 $^{\{3\}}$	0.28642 $^{\{8\}}$
		$\sum{Ranks}$	24 $^{\{2\}}$	73 $^{\{5.5\}}$	46 $^{\{4\}}$	73 $^{\{5.5\}}$	20 $^{\{1\}}$	74 $^{\{7\}}$	40 $^{\{3\}}$	82 $^{\{8\}}$

| Show Table

DownLoad: CSV

Table 3. Simulation results for

$\boldsymbol{\eta} = (\vartheta = 1.75, \varphi = 2 , \lambda = 1.5 , \theta = 2.5 )^{\intercal}$ .

$n$	Est.	Est. Par.	MLEs	LSEs	WLSEs	CRVMEs	MPSEs	PCEs	ADEs	RADEs
20	\|BIAS\|	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.58249 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.53932 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.56241 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.61397 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.60739 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.82341 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.68123 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.66592 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.70201 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.74992 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.71005 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.99334 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.41044 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	1.11769 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.88784 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.97457 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.26246 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.28717 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.28400 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.42881 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.40138 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.64545 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.43589 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.43050 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.83485 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.91523 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.92408 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.76222 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.77841 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.78092 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.74535 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.74828 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$
	MSEs	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.45340 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.42087 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.44427 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.51220 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.51720 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.77654 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.58720 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.56968 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.65182 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.75540 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.66110 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	1.25282 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.95641 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	1.49737 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	1.01553 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	1.19476 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.07059 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.08751 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.08543 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.29909 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.24742 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.52940 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.29252 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.29154 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.84612 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	1.00860 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	1.00532 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.71906 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.75325 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.82231 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.69565 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.70768 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$
	MREs	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.33285 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.30818 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.32138 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.35084 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.34708 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.47052 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.38927 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.38052 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.35100 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.37496 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.35503 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.49667 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.42863 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.55884 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.44392 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.48728 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.17497 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.19145 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.18933 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.28587 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.26758 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.43030 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.29059 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.28700 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.33394 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.36609 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.36963 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.30489 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.31136 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.31237 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.29814 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.29931 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$
		$\sum{Ranks}$	${\textbf{34}}$ $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	${\textbf{44}}$ $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	${\textbf{42}}$ $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	${\textbf{61}}$ $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	${\textbf{46}}$ $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	${\textbf{87}}$ $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	${\textbf{59}}$ $^{\left\{5.5 \right\}}$	${\textbf{59}}$ $^{\left\{5.5 \right\}}$
80	\|BIAS\|	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.49925 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.47135 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.52766 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.66329 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.55966 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.89224 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.67228 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.69447 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.52063 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.55025 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.52909 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.70683 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.56354 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.93582 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.63998 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.69954 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.25198 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.25883 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.25641 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.43311 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.30034 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.66563 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.40607 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.43206 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.78480 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.82532 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.83697 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.69063 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.58559 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.72122 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.63842 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.69164 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
	MSEs	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.31719 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.30026 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.34946 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.55815 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.49857 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.86629 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.56483 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.59417 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.27881 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.32553 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.29109 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.66883 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.44978 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	1.03760 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.55511 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.64550 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.06369 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.06795 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.06642 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.29117 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.15725 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.54984 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.25250 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.28331 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.66344 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.73666 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.74889 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.58730 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.45144 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.66717 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.51377 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.59201 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
	MREs	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.28529 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.26934 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.30152 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.37902 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.31981 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.50985 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.38416 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.39684 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.26032 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.27512 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.26454 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.35341 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.28177 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.46791 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.31999 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.34977 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.16798 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.17255 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.17094 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.28874 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.20023 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.44375 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.27071 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.28804 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.31392 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.33013 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.33479 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.27625 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.23423 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.28849 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.25537 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.27666 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
		$\sum{Ranks}$	${\textbf{29}}$ $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	${\textbf{42}}$ $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	${\textbf{45}}$ $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	${\textbf{66}}$ $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	${\textbf{39}}$ $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	${\textbf{88}}$ $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	${\textbf{54}}$ $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	${\textbf{69}}$ $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$
200	\|BIAS\|	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.47555 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.44985 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.51341 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.67707 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.42436 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.89805 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.66134 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.69895 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.50115 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.50837 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.50279 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.56296 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.41044 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.81679 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.51451 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.55936 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.25019 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.25187 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.25076 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.41917 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.21499 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.65544 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.37297 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.41435 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.79159 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.80107 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.82123 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.64647 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.43028 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.75308 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.57181 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.66234 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
	MSEs	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.25888 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.23847 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.29413 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.56097 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.37531 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.86783 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.54545 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.59107 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.25134 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.26082 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.25349 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.43952 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.25968 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.80523 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.37160 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.43084 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.06261 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.06361 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.06295 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.25891 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.09970 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.52619 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.20829 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.25203 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.64670 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.66161 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.69240 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.51309 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.27527 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.68347 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.41304 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.53268 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
	MREs	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.27175 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.25705 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.29338 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.38690 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.24249 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.51317 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.37791 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.39940 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.25057 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.25419 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.25139 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.28148 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.20522 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.40839 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.25725 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.27968 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.16679 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.16791 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.16717 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.27945 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.14333 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.43696 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.24865 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.27623 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.31664 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.32043 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.32849 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.25859 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.17211 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.30123 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.22872 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.26494 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
		$\sum{Ranks}$	${\textbf{35}}$ $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	${\textbf{48}}$ $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	${\textbf{51}}$ $^{\left\{4.5 \right\}}$	${\textbf{69}}$ $^{\left\{6.5 \right\}}$	${\textbf{20}}$ $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	${\textbf{89}}$ $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	${\textbf{51}}$ $^{\left\{4.5 \right\}}$	${\textbf{69}}$ $^{\left\{6.5 \right\}}$
500	\|BIAS\|	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.47314 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.44590 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.51215 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.64549 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.23589 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.89642 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.57765 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.66728 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.50000 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.50031 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.50001 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.44580 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.25497 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.66140 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.39329 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.42269 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.25000 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.25003 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.25001 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.38068 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.11500 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.63857 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.31593 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.38454 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.79445 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.80134 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.82604 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.59243 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.25280 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.80505 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.49356 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.61821 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
	MSEs	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.23703 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.21187 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.27432 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.51809 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.19898 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.86166 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.44538 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.54549 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.25000 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.25034 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.25001 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.28548 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.11705 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.56366 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.22462 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.25796 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.06250 $^{\left\{2.5 \right\}}$	0.06252 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.06250 $^{\left\{2.5 \right\}}$	0.20888 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.03935 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.50179 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.14873 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.20922 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.63903 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.64949 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.68943 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.43597 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.12546 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.74499 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.31912 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.46804 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
	MREs	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.27037 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.25480 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.29266 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.36885 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.13479 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.51224 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.33008 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.38130 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.25000 $^{\left\{5.5 \right\}}$	0.25015 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.25000 $^{\left\{5.5 \right\}}$	0.22290 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.12748 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.33070 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.19665 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.21134 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.16667 $^{\left\{2.5 \right\}}$	0.16669 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.16667 $^{\left\{2.5 \right\}}$	0.25379 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.07667 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.42571 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.21062 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.25636 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.31778 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.32053 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.33042 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.23697 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.10112 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.32202 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.19742 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.24728 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
		$\sum{Ranks}$	${\textbf{44.5}}$ $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	${\textbf{55}}$ $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	${\textbf{58.5}}$ $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	${\textbf{60}}$ $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	${\textbf{12}}$ $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	${\textbf{94}}$ $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	${\textbf{42}}$ $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	${\textbf{66}}$ $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$

| Show Table

DownLoad: CSV

Table 4. Simulation results for

$\boldsymbol{\eta} = (\vartheta = 3.5, \varphi = 0.75 , \lambda = 0.5 , \theta = 1.25 )^{\intercal}$ .

$n$	Est.	Est. Par.	MLEs	LSEs	WLSEs	CRVMEs	MPSEs	PCEs	ADEs	RADEs
20	\|BIAS\|	$\hat{\vartheta}$	1.05821 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.62985 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.96882 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.61879 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.39728 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	1.00062 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.93184 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.74851 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.58239 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.61540 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.57588 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.61442 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.16810 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.59648 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.54321 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.58344 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.09205 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.08984 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.08749 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.09161 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.07490 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.09181 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.08360 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.08890 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.65193 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.48317 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.52978 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.51841 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.37874 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.57738 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.51808 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.53685 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$
	MSEs	$\hat{\vartheta}$	1.62863 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.80009 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	1.26747 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.83422 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.44242 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	1.52407 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	1.26323 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	1.02485 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.42299 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.47351 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.43072 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.47310 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.39842 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.45399 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.39008 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.43912 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.01191 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.01157 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.01104 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.01199 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.00839 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.01226 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.01037 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.01130 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.56633 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.35145 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.39993 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.40530 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.22597 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.46238 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.39998 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.42492 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$
	MREs	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.30235 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.17996 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.27681 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.17680 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.11351 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.28589 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.26624 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.21386 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.77652 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.82054 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.76784 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.81923 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.73001 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.79531 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.72428 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.77792 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.18410 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.17968 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.17498 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.18321 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.14981 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.18363 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.16720 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.17780 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.52155 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.38654 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.42382 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.41473 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.30299 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.46190 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.41446 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.42948 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$
		$\sum{Ranks}$	${\textbf{81}}$ $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	${\textbf{53}}$ $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	${\textbf{50}}$ $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	${\textbf{60}}$ $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	${\textbf{14}}$ $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	${\textbf{82}}$ $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	${\textbf{35}}$ $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	${\textbf{57}}$ $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
80	\|BIAS\|	$\hat{\vartheta}$	1.30458 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.99944 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	1.19014 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	1.02885 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.28553 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	1.10670 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	1.14568 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	1.11457 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.32983 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.40620 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.34267 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.40746 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.27616 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.42471 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.32604 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.35934 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.06496 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.06255 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.05976 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.06558 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.03810 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.06030 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.05724 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.06303 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.60157 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.45112 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.47825 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.49541 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.19099 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.45370 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.45453 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.50033 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$
	MSEs	$\hat{\vartheta}$	1.98067 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	1.42246 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	1.62721 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	1.51028 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.28600 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	1.54773 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	1.54350 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	1.62460 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.16347 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.24145 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.17842 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.24070 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.12275 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.27309 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.16427 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.19753 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.00614 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.00590 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.00549 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.00646 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.00224 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.00582 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.00513 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.00600 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.50150 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.33442 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.35764 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.39078 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.06108 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.33595 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.33240 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.39877 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$
	MREs	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.37274 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.28555 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.34004 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.29396 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.08158 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.31620 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.32734 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.31845 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.43977 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.54161 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.45690 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.54328 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.36821 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.56628 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.43472 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.47912 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.12992 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.12509 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.11952 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.13116 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.07620 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.12061 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.11448 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.12607 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.48126 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.36089 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.38260 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.39633 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.15279 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.36296 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.36362 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.40027 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$
		$\sum{Ranks}$	${\textbf{77}}$ $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	${\textbf{47}}$ $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	${\textbf{57}}$ $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	${\textbf{71}}$ $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	${\textbf{12}}$ $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	${\textbf{59}}$ $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	${\textbf{39}}$ $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	${\textbf{70}}$ $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$
200	\|BIAS\|	$\hat{\vartheta}$	1.18071 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	1.13329 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	1.15680 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	1.15101 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.12881 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	1.09310 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	1.11947 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	1.17399 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.21288 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.27282 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.22827 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.28207 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.16810 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.31936 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.21687 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.23691 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.05455 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.05483 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.05139 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.05648 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.02373 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.04586 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.05000 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.05607 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.50995 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.46810 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.45161 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.48892 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.11088 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.36948 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.42847 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.48519 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$
	MSEs	$\hat{\vartheta}$	1.65210 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	1.59933 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	1.54359 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	1.65457 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.11230 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	1.41356 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	1.45126 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	1.65710 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.06995 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.11564 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.08167 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.12209 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.04607 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.16683 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.07397 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.08772 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.00441 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.00457 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.00403 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.00483 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.00088 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.00341 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.00386 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.00477 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.38578 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.35447 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.32071 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.38130 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.02076 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.24604 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.29346 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.38069 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$
	MREs	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.33734 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.32380 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.33052 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.32886 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.03680 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.31232 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.31985 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.33543 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.28384 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.36376 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.30437 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.37610 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.22413 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.42582 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.28917 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.31587 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.10910 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.10967 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.10278 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.11295 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.04745 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.09173 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.10000 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.11214 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.40796 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.37448 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.36129 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.39114 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.08871 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.29559 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.34277 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.38815 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$
		$\sum{Ranks}$	${\textbf{67}}$ $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	${\textbf{64}}$ $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	${\textbf{52}}$ $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	${\textbf{83}}$ $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	${\textbf{12}}$ $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	${\textbf{42}}$ $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	${\textbf{36}}$ $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	${\textbf{76}}$ $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$
500	\|BIAS\|	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.99609 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	1.12481 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	1.05940 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	1.12860 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.04256 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	1.04542 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	1.03887 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	1.14079 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.14496 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.18941 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.15844 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.19306 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.10411 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.23525 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.15349 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.16453 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.04309 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.05010 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.04425 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.04998 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.01474 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.03603 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.04334 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.05109 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.38900 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.44670 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.39875 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.45266 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.06374 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.31824 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.38560 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.45867 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$
	MSEs	$\hat{\vartheta}$	1.21294 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	1.50352 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	1.31440 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	1.52047 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.02893 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	1.25338 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	1.26686 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	1.51668 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.03263 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.05612 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.03902 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.05818 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.01736 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.09221 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.03639 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.04120 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.00278 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.00378 $^{\left\{6.5 \right\}}$	0.00295 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.00378 $^{\left\{6.5 \right\}}$	0.00034 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.00220 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.00283 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.00400 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.23678 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.31580 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.25000 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.32430 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.00703 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.18536 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.23280 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.33477 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$
	MREs	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.28460 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.32137 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.30269 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.32246 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.01216 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.29869 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.29682 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.32594 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.19328 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.25255 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.21126 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.25741 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.13881 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.31367 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.20466 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.21938 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.08617 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.10020 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.08850 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.09997 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.02948 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.07207 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.08669 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.10217 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.31120 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.35736 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.31900 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.36213 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.05100 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.25459 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.30848 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.36694 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$
		$\sum{Ranks}$	${\textbf{33}}$ $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	${\textbf{74.5}}$ $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	${\textbf{57}}$ $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	${\textbf{82.5}}$ $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	${\textbf{12}}$ $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	${\textbf{47}}$ $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	${\textbf{40}}$ $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	${\textbf{86}}$ $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$

| Show Table

DownLoad: CSV

Table 5. Simulation results for

$\boldsymbol{\eta} = (\vartheta = 3.5, \varphi = 2 , \lambda = 1.5 , \theta = 2.5 )^{\intercal}$ .

$n$	Est.	Est. Par.	MLEs	LSEs	WLSEs	CRVMEs	MPSEs	PCEs	ADEs	RADEs
20	\|BIAS\|	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.98923 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.64331 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.95672 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.63413 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.44818 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	1.04755 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.90857 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.78916 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.95367 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.90318 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.88553 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.95450 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.31253 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.97463 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.85825 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.93652 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.50387 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.29370 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.38814 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.31558 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.23477 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.41787 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.38863 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.36144 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.83605 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.71444 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.81238 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.68991 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.62151 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.74404 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.75604 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.71561 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
	MSEs	$\hat{\vartheta}$	1.35323 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.71389 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	1.18225 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.73718 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.37586 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	1.57224 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	1.13154 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	1.02701 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	1.18857 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	1.06788 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	1.02750 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	1.18599 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.87512 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	1.15778 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.96462 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	1.13400 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.36432 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.14714 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.22539 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.17712 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.09172 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.28638 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.23923 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.22267 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.77865 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.64926 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.77561 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.60519 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.52925 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.67762 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.68866 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.64046 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$
	MREs	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.28264 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.18380 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.27335 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.18118 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.12805 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.29930 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.25959 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.22547 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.47683 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.45159 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.44276 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.47725 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.40539 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.48731 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.42912 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.46826 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.33591 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.19580 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.25876 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.21038 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.15651 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.27858 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.25908 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.24096 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.33442 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.28578 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.32495 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.27596 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.24860 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.29762 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.30242 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.28624 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
		$\sum{Ranks}$	${\textbf{89}}$ $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	${\textbf{36}}$ $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	${\textbf{63}}$ $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	${\textbf{43}}$ $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	${\textbf{12}}$ $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	${\textbf{82}}$ $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	${\textbf{57}}$ $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	${\textbf{50}}$ $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
80	\|BIAS\|	$\hat{\vartheta}$	1.00512 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.76116 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.98814 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.76068 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.22490 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.94177 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.95845 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.83406 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.56247 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.64453 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.57353 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.64522 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.46925 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.76277 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.55915 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.63949 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.45485 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.31115 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.36895 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.33000 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.11306 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.39112 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.36093 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.34405 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.76702 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.62063 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.68635 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.62598 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.33066 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.60384 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.66063 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.63130 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
	MSEs	$\hat{\vartheta}$	1.24539 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.92842 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	1.16588 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.94580 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.13919 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	1.25646 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	1.12647 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	1.05555 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.45689 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.57098 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.46410 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.57244 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.32482 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.71835 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.44181 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.55971 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.28629 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.17260 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.20504 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.19582 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.02220 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.25122 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.20232 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.20735 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.68706 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.51170 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.58072 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.52071 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.16747 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.49400 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.55280 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.52733 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
	MREs	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.28718 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.21747 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.28233 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.21734 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.06426 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.26908 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.27384 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.23830 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.28123 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.32226 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.28677 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.32261 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.23462 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.38138 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.27957 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.31974 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.30323 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.20744 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.24597 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.22000 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.07538 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.26075 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.24062 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.22937 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.30681 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.24825 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.27454 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.25039 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.13226 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.24153 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.26425 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.25252 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
		$\sum{Ranks}$	${\textbf{80}}$ $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	${\textbf{41}}$ $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	${\textbf{70}}$ $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	${\textbf{49}}$ $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	${\textbf{12}}$ $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	${\textbf{69}}$ $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	${\textbf{55}}$ $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	${\textbf{56}}$ $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
200	\|BIAS\|	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.98460 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.86500 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	1.00674 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.86298 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.12154 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	1.05269 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.98185 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.89235 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.38859 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.45911 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.41129 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.46722 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.31253 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.67732 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.40329 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.46920 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.39873 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.31023 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.35370 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.32546 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.06881 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.37938 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.34126 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.32900 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.68985 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.57483 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.64129 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.59868 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.21029 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.55195 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.61763 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.59808 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
	MSEs	$\hat{\vartheta}$	1.11626 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	1.01791 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	1.13048 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	1.02064 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.05498 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	1.30905 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	1.09868 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	1.05550 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.23053 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.31234 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.25573 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.32276 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.15678 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.58268 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.24649 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.32421 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.22103 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.16583 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.18036 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.17985 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.00837 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.22479 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.17270 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.18259 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.58585 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.45832 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.51809 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.48976 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.07171 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.44322 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.49209 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.48968 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
	MREs	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.28132 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.24714 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.28764 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.24657 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.03472 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.30077 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.28053 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.25496 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.19429 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.22956 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.20564 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.23361 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.15627 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.33866 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.20165 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.23460 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.26582 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.20682 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.23580 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.21697 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.04587 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.25292 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.22751 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.21933 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.27594 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.22993 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.25652 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.23947 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.08412 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.22078 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.24705 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.23923 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
		$\sum{Ranks}$	${\textbf{71}}$ $^{\left\{6.5 \right\}}$	${\textbf{38}}$ $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	${\textbf{71}}$ $^{\left\{6.5 \right\}}$	${\textbf{50}}$ $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	${\textbf{12}}$ $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	${\textbf{76}}$ $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	${\textbf{55}}$ $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	${\textbf{59}}$ $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
500	\|BIAS\|	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.93304 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.93263 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.97539 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.92961 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.05348 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	1.08240 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.95522 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.92527 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.27572 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.32936 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.29210 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.33160 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.19113 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.58412 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.28766 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.33820 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.34882 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.31976 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.33838 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.33117 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.03908 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.35124 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.32736 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.32969 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.61892 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.57580 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.60923 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.59341 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.12272 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.51040 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.59246 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.58416 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
	MSEs	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.99386 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	1.04383 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	1.04849 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	1.04352 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.00732 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	1.28318 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	1.01861 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	1.03056 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.11591 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.16651 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.13079 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.16807 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.06394 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.45248 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.12739 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.17250 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.17000 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.15789 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.15993 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.16663 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.00250 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.18698 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.15186 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.16915 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.48714 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.45146 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.47250 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.47497 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.02504 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.39915 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.45105 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.47078 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
	MREs	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.26658 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.26647 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.27868 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.26560 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.01528 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.30926 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.27292 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.26436 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.13786 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.16468 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.14605 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.16580 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.09557 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.29206 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.14383 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.16910 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.23255 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.21318 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.22559 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.22078 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.02606 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.23416 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.21824 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.21980 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.24757 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.23032 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.24369 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.23736 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.04909 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.20416 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.23698 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.23367 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
		$\sum{Ranks}$	${\textbf{63}}$ $^{\left\{5.5 \right\}}$	${\textbf{46}}$ $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	${\textbf{69}}$ $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	${\textbf{63}}$ $^{\left\{5.5 \right\}}$	${\textbf{12}}$ $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	${\textbf{78}}$ $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	${\textbf{45}}$ $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	${\textbf{56}}$ $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$

| Show Table

DownLoad: CSV

Table 6. Simulation results for

$\boldsymbol{\eta} = (\vartheta = 4.5, \varphi = 0.75 , \lambda = 0.5 , \theta = 1.25 )^{\intercal}$ .

$n$	Est.	Est. Par.	MLEs	LSEs	WLSEs	CRVMEs	MPSEs	PCEs	ADEs	RADEs
20	\|BIAS\|	$\hat{\vartheta}$	1.25197 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.45438 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	1.06521 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.44888 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.20680 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.83805 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	1.02528 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.62513 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.58123 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.60203 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.57995 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.61278 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.16575 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.57749 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.53508 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.58165 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.08854 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.07652 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.08227 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.07831 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.06474 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.08065 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.07939 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.07980 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.66759 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.42262 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.53041 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.44839 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.32466 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.51024 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.52797 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.48959 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
	MSEs	$\hat{\vartheta}$	2.41625 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.60512 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	1.67131 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.67908 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.18285 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	1.58289 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	1.74298 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	1.01407 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.42148 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.46192 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.43565 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.46874 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.38218 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.43432 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.38271 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.43679 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.01072 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.00870 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.00963 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.00906 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.00620 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.00950 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.00923 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.00919 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.58894 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.28693 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.40885 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.32249 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.16767 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.38646 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.41599 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.36863 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
	MREs	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.27821 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.10097 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.23671 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.09975 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.04596 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.18623 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.22784 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.13892 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.77497 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.80271 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.77327 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.81704 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.70903 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.76998 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.71344 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.77554 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.17707 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.15303 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.16453 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.15662 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.12948 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.16130 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.15879 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.15960 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.53407 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.33809 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.42432 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.35871 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.25973 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.40819 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.42237 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.39167 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
		$\sum{Ranks}$	${\textbf{85}}$ $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	${\textbf{41}}$ $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	${\textbf{74}}$ $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	${\textbf{49}}$ $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	${\textbf{12}}$ $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	${\textbf{58}}$ $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	${\textbf{57}}$ $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	${\textbf{56}}$ $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
80	\|BIAS\|	$\hat{\vartheta}$	1.62748 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.91367 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	1.37823 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.98139 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.11224 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	1.13720 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	1.31803 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	1.11805 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.31837 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.39968 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.34474 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.40380 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.27352 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.37466 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.31821 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.35079 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.07169 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.05804 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.06253 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.06113 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.03286 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.05699 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.05980 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.05870 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.64853 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.39956 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.49396 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.44278 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.16292 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.43570 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.47512 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.45276 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
	MSEs	$\hat{\vartheta}$	3.14585 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	1.58782 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	2.33956 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	1.79431 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.08679 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	1.96177 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	2.22845 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	2.05141 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.15254 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.23761 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.18156 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.24031 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.12335 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.22013 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.15798 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.19064 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.00707 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.00520 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.00579 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.00566 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.00171 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.00514 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.00541 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.00519 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.56658 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.28713 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.38674 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.34041 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.04197 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.32550 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.36722 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.35156 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
	MREs	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.36166 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.20304 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.30627 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.21809 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.02494 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.25271 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.29289 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.24846 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.42449 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.53291 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.45966 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.53840 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.36469 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.49955 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.42429 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.46771 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.14337 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.11609 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.12506 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.12226 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.06572 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.11399 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.11961 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.11740 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.51882 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.31965 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.39517 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.35422 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.13034 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.34856 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.38010 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.36221 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
		$\sum{Ranks}$	${\textbf{80}}$ $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	${\textbf{43}}$ $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	${\textbf{75}}$ $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	${\textbf{63}}$ $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	${\textbf{12}}$ $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	${\textbf{47}}$ $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	${\textbf{58}}$ $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	${\textbf{54}}$ $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$
200	\|BIAS\|	$\hat{\vartheta}$	1.48139 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	1.17284 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	1.40391 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	1.21294 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.04307 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	1.17950 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	1.33404 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	1.29174 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.20186 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.26830 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.21385 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.26575 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.16575 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.27408 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.20558 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.23166 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.06056 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.05260 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.05573 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.05571 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.02038 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.04542 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.05309 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.05470 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.54563 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.42847 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.47838 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.45810 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.09746 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.36816 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.44966 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.46232 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$
	MSEs	$\hat{\vartheta}$	2.63270 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	2.08923 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	2.37558 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	2.20468 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.02535 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	1.86391 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	2.18628 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	2.32684 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.06343 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.11259 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.07126 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.11064 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.04499 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.12626 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.06649 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.08397 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.00531 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.00437 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.00472 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.00486 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.00066 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.00347 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.00441 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.00470 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.44122 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.33416 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.37078 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.37139 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.01519 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.25838 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.33754 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.37704 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$
	MREs	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.32920 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.26063 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.31198 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.26954 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.00957 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.26211 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.29645 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.28705 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.26915 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.35774 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.28513 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.35434 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.22100 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.36544 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.27411 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.30888 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.12113 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.10520 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.11146 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.11142 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.04075 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.09084 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.10618 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.10941 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.43650 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.34278 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.38270 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.36648 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.07797 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.29453 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.35973 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.36986 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$
		$\sum{Ranks}$	${\textbf{78}}$ $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	${\textbf{46}}$ $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	${\textbf{72}}$ $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	${\textbf{66}}$ $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	${\textbf{12}}$ $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	${\textbf{44}}$ $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	${\textbf{49}}$ $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	${\textbf{65}}$ $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
500	\|BIAS\|	$\hat{\vartheta}$	1.29672 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	1.27235 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	1.31237 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	1.32513 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.01519 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	1.15120 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	1.28994 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	1.34189 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.13744 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.17802 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.14815 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.18664 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.10227 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.19392 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.14640 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.15865 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.04970 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.05107 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.04913 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.05400 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.01264 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.03665 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.04825 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.05335 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.44102 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.44509 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.43050 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.47518 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.05962 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.31796 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.42160 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.46945 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$
	MSEs	$\hat{\vartheta}$	2.07266 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	2.19148 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	2.07839 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	2.34226 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.00344 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	1.67247 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	2.02330 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	2.31957 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.02955 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.05030 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.03417 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.05288 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.01679 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.06276 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.03295 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.03874 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.00377 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.00418 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.00378 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.00452 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.00025 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.00242 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.00363 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.00454 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.30987 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.34423 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.30505 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.37795 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.00564 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.19875 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.29242 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.37470 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$
	MREs	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.28816 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.28275 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.29164 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.29447 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.00337 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.25582 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.28665 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.29820 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\varphi}$	0.18326 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.23736 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.19754 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.24885 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$	0.13636 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.25856 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.19520 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.21153 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\lambda}$	0.09940 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.10214 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.09825 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.10801 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.02528 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.07330 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.09651 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.10671 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$
		$\hat{\theta}$	0.35281 $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	0.35607 $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	0.34440 $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	0.38014 $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	0.04770 $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	0.25437 $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	0.33728 $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	0.37556 $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$
		$\sum{Ranks}$	${\textbf{49}}$ $^{\left\{4 \right\}}$	${\textbf{66}}$ $^{\left\{6 \right\}}$	${\textbf{54}}$ $^{\left\{5 \right\}}$	${\textbf{90}}$ $^{\left\{8 \right\}}$	${\textbf{12}}$ $^{\left\{1 \right\}}$	${\textbf{42}}$ $^{\left\{3 \right\}}$	${\textbf{38}}$ $^{\left\{2 \right\}}$	${\textbf{81}}$ $^{\left\{7 \right\}}$

| Show Table

DownLoad: CSV

All computations are obtained using R software (version 4.0.2) ^[22].

For each sample and each parametric combination, the EWFr parameters $\vartheta$ , $\varphi$ , $\lambda$ and $\theta$ are estimated using the eight estimators called MLEs, LSEs, WLSEs, MPSEs, CRVMEs, ADEs, PCEs, and RADEs. Simulated results are listed in – which also indicate the ranks of each of the proposed estimators in each row, where the superscripts show the indicators, and the $\sum Ranks$ illustrates the partial sum of ranks in each column for a particular sample size.

Table 7 lists the partial and overall ranks for all parametric combinations. From Tables 2–6, one can conclude that all methods of estimation illustrate the consistency property, that is, the MREs and MSEs decrease as the sample size increases, for all parametric combinations. Table 7 shows that the MPS approach has an overall score of 54, hence it outperforms other estimation methods. Therefore, we conclude and confirm the superiority of MPSEs for estimating the EWFr parameters. However, the ADEs and MLEs are approximately have a similar performance, where their overall scores are, respectively, 130.5 and 133.5.

Table 7. Partial and overall ranks of the classical estimation methods for several parametric values.

$\mathit{\boldsymbol{\eta}}^{\intercal}$	n	MLEs	LSEs	WLSEs	CRVMEs	MPSEs	PCEs	ADEs	RADEs
$(\hat{\vartheta}=1.75, \hat{\varphi}=0.5, \hat{\lambda}=0.25, \hat{\theta}=1.25)$	20	2	7	1	5	4	8	3	6
	80	3	7	2	6	1	5	4	8
	200	1.5	7	4	5	1.5	6	3	8
	500	2	5.5	4	5.5	1	7	3	8
$(\hat{\vartheta}=1.75, \hat{\varphi}=2, \hat{\lambda}=1.5, \hat{\theta}=2.5)$	20	1	3	2	7	4	8	5.5	5.5
	80	1	3	4	6	2	8	5	7
	200	2	3	4.5	6.5	1	8	4.5	6.5
	500	3	4	5	6	1	8	2	7
$(\hat{\vartheta}=3.5, \hat{\varphi}=0.75, \hat{\lambda}=0.5, \hat{\theta}=1.25)$	20	7	4	3	6	1	8	2	5
	80	8	3	4	7	1	5	2	6
	200	6	5	4	8	1	3	2	7
	500	2	6	5	7	1	4	3	8
$(\hat{\vartheta}=3.5, \hat{\varphi}=2, \hat{\lambda}=1.5, \hat{\theta}=2.5)$	20	8	2	6	3	1	7	5	4
	80	8	2	7	3	1	6	4	5
	200	6.5	2	6.5	3	1	8	4	5
	500	5.5	3	7	5.5	1	8	2	4
$(\hat{\vartheta}=4.5, \hat{\varphi}=0.75, \hat{\lambda}=0.5, \hat{\theta}=1.25)$	20	8	2	7	3	1	6	5	4
	80	8	2	7	6	1	3	5	4
	200	8	3	7	6	1	2	4	5
	500	4	6	5	8	1	3	2	7
$(\hat{\vartheta}=4.5, \hat{\varphi}=0.75, \hat{\lambda}=0.5, \hat{\theta}=1.25)$	20	8	2	5	3	1	7	6	4
	80	6	2	4	3	1	8	7	5
	200	6	2	4	3	1	7	8	5
	500	6	2	5	3	1	8	7	4
$(\hat{\vartheta}=0.25, \hat{\varphi}=3.5, \hat{\lambda}=3, \hat{\theta}=0.25)$	20	1	6	8	2	7	5	4	3
	80	1.5	5	8	1.5	6	4	3	7
	200	1	7	4	6	2	3	5	8
	500	2	8	6	7	1	3	4.5	4.5
$(\hat{\vartheta}=0.75, \hat{\varphi}=2.5, \hat{\lambda}=4.25, \hat{\theta}=0.25)$	20	2	8	6	5	3	1	4	7
	80	1.5	7	5	6	1.5	3	4	8
	200	2	7	5	6	1	3	4	8
	500	2	8	5	6	1	3	4	7
$\sum Ranks$		$\textbf{133.5}$	$\textbf{143.5}$	$\textbf{160}$	$\textbf{164}$	$\textbf{54}$	$\textbf{176}$	$\textbf{130.5}$	$\textbf{190.5}$
${\textbf{Overall Rank}}$		$\textbf{3}$	$\textbf{4}$	$\textbf{5}$	$\textbf{6}$	$\textbf{1}$	$\textbf{7}$	$\textbf{2}$	$\textbf{8}$

| Show Table

DownLoad: CSV

5. Modeling medicine and engineering data

In this section, the flexibility and importance of the EWFr distribution in modeling real-life data are illustrated using two datasets from the medicine and engineering fields. The first dataset contains $128$ observations and it refers to remission times (in months) for bladder cancer patients ^[23]. The second dataset contains $63$ observations and it represents strengths for single carbon fibers of $10$ mm of gauge lengths ^[24]. The fits of the EWFr distribution is checked and compared with some important extensions of the Fr distribution called the exponentiated-Fr (EFr) ^[6], beta-Fr (BFr) ^[7], odd Lomax-Fr (OLxFr) ^[25], Kumaraswamy Marshall–Olkin Fr (KMOFr) ^[26], gamma extended-Fr (GExFr) ^[27] and transmuted exponentiated-Fr (TEFr) ^[28] and Fr distributions.

We checked the competing distributions using some goodness-of-fit analytical measures such as AIC (Akaike information criterion), CAIC (consistent Akaike information criterion), HQIC (Hannan–Quinn information criterion), BIC (Bayesian information criterion), $W^{\ast}$ (Cramér–Von Mises), $A^{\ast}$ (Anderson–Darling), and KS (Kolmogorov–Smirnov) statistics with its PV (p-value).

The maximum likelihood (ML) estimates of the parameters of the fitted distributions, their standard errors (SEs), and the analytical measures are reported in Tables 8 and 9 for the cancer and gauge lengths data, respectively. The numbers in Tables 8 and 9 indicate that the EWFr distribution gives a superior fit over other competing models, since it has the lowest values for all measures and the largest PV.

Table 8. The parameters estimates of the competing distributions and goodness-of-fit measures for cancer data.

Model	Par..	Estimates	(SEs)	AIC	CAIC	BIC	HQIC	$W^{*}$	$A^{*}$	KS	(PV)
EWFr	$\hat{\vartheta}$	56.93662	(38.42845)	827.52150	827.84670	838.92960	832.15660	0.01991	0.13402	0.03757	0.99713
	$\hat{\varphi}$	0.46697	(0.22382)
	$\hat{\lambda}$	0.71825	(0.01713)
	$\hat{\theta}$	0.01794	(0.01207)
OLxFr	$\hat{\vartheta}$	2.18260	(1.04763)	827.70270	828.02790	839.11080	832.33780	0.02380	0.16520	0.04060	0.98433
	$\hat{\varphi}$	625.38000	(622.71234)
	$\hat{a}$	0.12210	(0.08023)
	$\hat{b}$	1.38560	(0.17273)
KMOFr	$\hat{\vartheta}$	43.87750	(128.52731)	831.05330	831.54510	845.31340	836.84730	0.26278	0.34950	0.04457	0.96120
	$\hat{\varphi}$	0.52028	(0.41388)
	$\hat{\delta}$	0.01314	(0.00808)
	$\hat{a}$	3.27359	(2.90929)
	$\hat{b}$	19.93782	(47.58906)
EFr	$\hat{a}$	1426.40000	(1440.19245)	830.85880	831.05240	839.41490	834.33520	0.06720	0.46640	0.04910	0.91754
	$\hat{b}$	0.26240	(0.02850)
	$\hat{\theta}$	46.24800	(22.87321)
BFr	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.60970	(0.32261)	833.09830	833.42350	844.50640	837.73350	0.06900	0.47650	0.05540	0.82683
	$\hat{\varphi}$	36.60200	(19.48341)
	$\hat{a}$	739.38700	(629.24021)
	$\hat{b}$	0.32240	(0.06044)
GExFr	$\hat{\vartheta}$	226.67000	(267.96324)	840.21630	840.54150	851.62450	844.85150	0.14320	0.95970	0.06640	0.62593
	$\hat{\varphi}$	91.93900	(133.94324)
	$\hat{a}$	22.27100	(119.19139)
	$\hat{b}$	0.07090	(0.04132)
TEFr	$\hat{\vartheta}$	3.25820	(0.40714)	892.00150	892.09750	897.70560	894.31910	0.74430	4.54640	0.14080	0.01254
	$\hat{\varphi}$	0.75210	(0.04224)
	$\hat{a}$	39.38721	(40.24321)
	$\hat{b}$	0.25243	(0.76041)
Fr	$\hat{\theta}$	0.75208	(0.04242)	892.00150	892.09750	897.70560	894.31910	0.74432	4.54642	0.14079	0.01250
Fr	$\hat{\lambda}$	2.43109	(0.21928)	892.00150	892.09750	897.70560	894.31910	0.74432	4.54642	0.14079	0.01250

| Show Table

DownLoad: CSV

Table 9. The parameters estimates of the competing distributions and goodness-of-fit measures for gauge lengths data.

Model	Par..	Estimates	(SEs)	AIC	CAIC	BIC	HQIC	$W^{*}$	$A^{*}$	KS	(PV)
EWFr	$\hat{\vartheta}$	0.76563	(0.3765631)	119.68850	120.37820	128.26110	123.06020	0.04181	0.23988	0.06847	0.92920
	$\hat{\varphi}$	0.04349	(0.3074545)
	$\hat{\lambda}$	145.67068	(208.851634)
	$\hat{\theta}$	4.60846	(1.2033681)
OLxFr	$\hat{\vartheta}$	5.14301	(9.9790719)	119.94170	120.63140	128.51430	123.31340	0.04741	0.26530	0.07631	0.85664
	$\hat{\varphi}$	5.82568	(7.6204045)
	$\hat{a}$	4.17374	(2.671917)
	$\hat{b}$	2.82338	(0.9308868)
KMOFr	$\hat{\vartheta}$	31946.70000	(837.7074)	121.90480	122.95750	132.62050	126.11940	0.04616	0.26108	0.07450	0.87551
	$\hat{\varphi}$	3.40405	(1.493079)
	$\hat{\delta}$	3.35291	(0.9682264)
	$\hat{a}$	0.85381	(0.1934628)
	$\hat{b}$	13724.50000	(32837.29)
EFr	$\hat{a}$	2.58672	(2.2847576)	122.19730	122.88700	130.76990	125.56900	0.07082	0.40707	0.08894	0.70136
	$\hat{b}$	0.50304	(0.4780356)
	$\hat{\theta}$	6.25000	(10.0300775)
BFr	$\hat{\vartheta}$	2.38748	(5.65075)	120.58420	121.27380	129.15670	123.95580	0.06008	0.32203	0.07953	0.82045
	$\hat{\varphi}$	1.00168	(5.322252)
	$\hat{a}$	22.38231	(162.860747)
	$\hat{b}$	27.37096	(295.790324)
GExFr	$\hat{\vartheta}$	2.41716	(8.509608)	120.57980	121.26950	129.15240	123.95150	0.06064	0.32329	0.07962	0.81934
	$\hat{\varphi}$	1.20859	(2.106142)
	$\hat{a}$	24.77784	(82.649275)
	$\hat{b}$	15.60163	(85.339807)
TEFr	$\hat{\vartheta}$	4.04638	(1.0119058)	121.04420	121.73390	129.61670	124.41580	0.06547	0.34378	0.07500	0.87047
	$\hat{\varphi}$	2.50000	(0.5973595)
	$\hat{a}$	5.25000	(2.6300897)
	$\hat{b}$	0.09255	(1.2750272)
Fr	$\hat{\theta}$	5.43392	(0.50788)	121.80430	122.00430	126.09060	123.49010	0.11497	0.64202	0.10013	0.55274
Fr	$\hat{\lambda}$	230.48644	(110.91778)	121.80430	122.00430	126.09060	123.49010	0.11497	0.64202	0.10013	0.55274

| Show Table

DownLoad: CSV

Some plots including the PDF, CDF, and SF along with the PP plots of the EWFr model are displayed in Figure 3 for both datasets. The PP plots of all studied distributions are displayed in Figure 4 for the two datasets, respectively.

Figure 3. The fitted EWFr PDF, CDF, SF, and P-P plots of the EWFr distribution.

DownLoad: Full-Size Img PowerPoint

Figure 4. The PP plots of the EWFr distribution and other distributions.

DownLoad: Full-Size Img PowerPoint

The estimates of the EWFr parameters under several estimation approaches and the goodness-of-fit measures for both datasets are listed in Tables 10 and 11, respectively. Based on the values of PV in Tables 10 and 11, the Anderson-Darling approach is recommended to estimate the EWFr parameters for cancer data, while the least-squares approach is recommended for gauge lengths data.

Table 10. The estimates of the EWFr parameters under several methods of estimation and analytical measures for cancer data.

Methods	$\hat{\vartheta}$	$\hat{\varphi}$	$\hat{\lambda}$	$\hat{\theta}$	$W^{*}$	$A^{*}$	KS	PV
MLEs	56.93661	0.46697	0.71825	0.01794	0.01991	0.13402	0.03757	0.99713
LSEs	56.93660	0.55502	0.71932	0.01871	0.01850	0.12986	0.03334	0.99918
MPSEs	56.93660	0.46698	0.71750	0.01717	0.01916	0.13069	0.03617	0.99708
WLSEs	56.94615	0.51962	0.71884	0.01825	0.01815	0.12600	0.03251	0.99947
CRVMEs	56.93659	0.55064	0.71962	0.01891	0.01795	0.12584	0.03352	0.99910
ADEs	56.93668	0.47772	0.71887	0.01815	0.01763	0.12016	0.03167	0.99968
PCEs	57.47389	0.81500	0.72219	0.02155	0.03320	0.23254	0.03830	0.99367
RADEs	56.93805	0.56319	0.71967	0.01899	0.01830	0.12878	0.03385	0.99895

| Show Table

DownLoad: CSV

Table 11. The estimates of the EWFr parameters under several methods of estimation and analytical measures for gauge lengths data.

$\textbf{Methods}$	$\hat{\vartheta}$	$\hat{\varphi}$	$\hat{\lambda}$	$\hat{\theta}$	$W^{*}$	$A^{*}$	$\textbf{KS}$	$\textbf{PV}$
$\textbf{MLEs}$	0.76563	0.04349	145.67068	4.60846	0.04181	0.23988	0.06847	0.92920
$\textbf{LSEs}$	0.69421	0.08110	145.67010	4.56661	0.04850	0.26973	0.06486	0.94154
$\textbf{MPSEs}$	0.75534	0.13947	145.66920	4.65631	0.05531	0.29551	0.07780	0.81897
$\textbf{WLSEs}$	0.71596	0.01530	145.66740	4.57637	0.04747	0.26675	0.06895	0.90999
$\textbf{CRVMEs}$	0.71398	0.00100	145.67030	4.57259	0.04761	0.26713	0.06733	0.92336
$\textbf{ADEs}$	0.72963	0.00010	145.67980	4.57988	0.04696	0.26562	0.07047	0.89642
$\textbf{PCEs}$	0.75075	0.02596	145.67020	4.59649	0.04775	0.26737	0.07311	0.87060
$\textbf{RADEs}$	0.74062	0.00010	145.66970	4.57722	0.04668	0.26516	0.07058	0.89538

| Show Table

DownLoad: CSV

6. Conclusions

In this paper, we introduced a more flexible four-parameter model called the extended Weibull–Fréchet (EWFr) distribution. Its basic mathematical properties are explored. The EWFr parameters are estimated using eight classical estimation methods. The simulation results showed that the maximum product of spacings approach outperforms other considered methods based on overall ranks. The importance and flexibility of the EWFr distribution over some competing extensions of the Fréchet distribution are addressed by analyzing two real-life datasets from the medicine and engineering fields. The analytical measures showed that our EWFr model returned an adequate fit in comparison with other distributions.

Acknowledgments

This study was funded by Taif University Researchers Supporting Project number (TURSP-2020/279), Taif University, Taif, Saudi Arabia. The authors would like to thank the editorial board and the three referees for their constructive comments that improved the final version of the paper.

Conflict of interest

The authors declare no conflict of interest.

References

[1]	S. M. Allen, J. W. Cahn, A microscopic theory for antiphase boundary motion and its application to antiphase domain coarsening, Acta Metall., 27 (1979), 1085–1095. https://doi.org/10.1016/0001-6160(79)90196-2 doi: 10.1016/0001-6160(79)90196-2
[2]	W. Xie, Q. Xia, Q. Yu, Y. Li, An effective phase field method for topology optimization without the curvature effects, Comput. Math. Appl., 146 (2023), 200–212. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.camwa.2023.06.037 doi: 10.1016/j.camwa.2023.06.037
[3]	Y. Wang, J. Yang, X. Xiao, X. Feng, Efficient numerical simulation for the dendritic crystal growth with melt convection in complex domains, Int. J. Heat Mass Transfer, 233 (2024), 126036. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijheatmasstransfer.2024.126036 doi: 10.1016/j.ijheatmasstransfer.2024.126036
[4]	Y. Li, K. Qin, Q. Xia, J. Kim, A second-order unconditionally stable method for the anisotropic dendritic crystal growth model with an orientation-field, Appl. Numer. Math., 184 (2023), 512–526. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apnum.2022.11.006 doi: 10.1016/j.apnum.2022.11.006
[5]	C. Liu, Z. Qiao, Q. Zhang, Multi-phase image segmentation by the Allen–Cahn Chan–Vese model, Comput. Math. Appl., 141 (2023), 207–220. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.camwa.2022.12.020 doi: 10.1016/j.camwa.2022.12.020
[6]	Q. Xia, J. Kim, B. Xia, Y. Li, An unconditionally energy stable method for binary incompressible heat conductive fluids based on the phase-field model, Comput. Math. Appl., 123 (2022), 26–39. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.camwa.2022.07.022 doi: 10.1016/j.camwa.2022.07.022
[7]	Q. Xia, Y. Liu, J. Kim, Y. Li, Binary thermal fluids computation over arbitrary surfaces with second-order accuracy and unconditional energy stability based on phase-field model, J. Comput. Appl. Math., 433 (2023), 115319. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cam.2023.115319 doi: 10.1016/j.cam.2023.115319
[8]	Z. Lu, J. Wang, A novel and efficient multi-scale feature extraction method for EEG classification, AIMS Math., 9 (2024), 16605–16622. https://doi.org/10.3934/math.2024805 doi: 10.3934/math.2024805
[9]	S. Sun, Q. Gong, Y. Ni, M. Yi, A micromagnetic-mechanically coupled phase-field model for fracture and fatigue of magnetostrictive alloys, J. Mech. Phys. Solids, 191 (2024), 105767. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmps.2024.105767 doi: 10.1016/j.jmps.2024.105767
[10]	Z. Wang, G. Wang, A coupled MPM and CBFEM framework for large deformation simulation of porous media interacting with pore and free fluid, Comput. Geotech., 163 (2023), 105746. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compgeo.2023.105746 doi: 10.1016/j.compgeo.2023.105746
[11]	B. Xia, X. Xi, R. Yu, P. Zhang, Unconditional energy-stable method for the Swift–Hohenberg equation over arbitrarily curved surfaces with second-order accuracy, Appl. Numer. Math., 198 (2024), 192–201. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apnum.2024.01.005 doi: 10.1016/j.apnum.2024.01.005
[12]	X. Hu, Q. Xia, B. Xia, Y. Li, A second-order accurate numerical method with unconditional energy stability for the Lifshitz–Petrich equation on curved surfaces, Appl. Math. Lett., 163 (2025), 109439. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aml.2024.109439 doi: 10.1016/j.aml.2024.109439
[13]	M. Raissi, P. Perdikaris, G. E. Karniadakis, Physics-informed neural networks: A deep learning framework for solving forward and inverse problems involving nonlinear partial differential equations, J. Comput. Phys., 378 (2019), 686–707. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jcp.2018.10.045 doi: 10.1016/j.jcp.2018.10.045
[14]	C. L. Wight, J. Zhao, Solving Allen–Cahn and Cahn–Hilliard equations using the adaptive physics informed neural networks, Commun. Comput. Phys., 29 (2021), 930–954. https://doi.org/10.4208/cicp.OA-2020-0086 doi: 10.4208/cicp.OA-2020-0086
[15]	X. Song, B. Xia, Y. Li, An efficient data assimilation based unconditionally stable scheme for Cahn–Hilliard equation, Comput. Appl. Math., 43 (2024), 121. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40314-024-02632-7 doi: 10.1007/s40314-024-02632-7
[16]	X. Song, Q. Xia, J. Kim, Y. Li, An unconditional energy stable data assimilation scheme for Navier–Stokes–Cahn–Hilliard equations with local discretized observed data, Comput. Math. Appl., 164 (2024), 21–33. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.camwa.2024.03.018 doi: 10.1016/j.camwa.2024.03.018
[17]	Y. Li, R. Liu, Q. Xia, C. He, Z. Li, First- and second-order unconditionally stable direct discretization methods for multi-component Cahn–Hilliard system on surfaces, J. Comput. Appl. Math., 401 (2022), 113778. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cam.2021.113778 doi: 10.1016/j.cam.2021.113778
[18]	X. Meng, Z. Li, D. Zhang, G. E. Karniadakis, PPINN: Parareal physics-informed neural network for time-dependent PDEs, Comput. Methods Appl. Mech. Eng., 370 (2020), 113250. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cma.2020.113250 doi: 10.1016/j.cma.2020.113250
[19]	A. D. Jagtap, E. Kharazmi, G. E. Karniadakis, Conservative physics-informed neural networks on discrete domains for conservation laws: Applications to forward and inverse problems, Comput. Methods Appl. Mech. Eng., 365 (2020), 113028. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cma.2020.113028 doi: 10.1016/j.cma.2020.113028
[20]	L. Lu, X. Meng, Z. Mao, G. E. Karniadakis, Deepxde: A deep learning library for solving differential equations, SIAM Rev., 63 (2021), 208–228. https://doi.org/10.1137/19M1274067 doi: 10.1137/19M1274067
[21]	S. J. Anagnostopoulos, J. D. Toscano, N. Stergiopulos, G. E. Karniadakis, Residual-based attention in physics-informed neural networks, Comput. Mech., 42 (2024), 1273–1285. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cma.2024.116805 doi: 10.1016/j.cma.2024.116805
[22]	P. Roy, S. T. Castonguay, Exact enforcement of temporal continuity in sequential physics-informed neural networks, Comput. Methods Appl. Mech. Eng., 430 (2024), 117197. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cma.2024.117197 doi: 10.1016/j.cma.2024.117197
[23]	S. Monaco, D. Apiletti, Training physics-informed neural networks: One learning to rule them all, Results Eng., 18 (2023), 101023. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rineng.2023.101023 doi: 10.1016/j.rineng.2023.101023
[24]	X. Huang, T. Alkhalifah, Efficient physics-informed neural networks using hash encoding, J. Comput. Phys., 501 (2024), 112760. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jcp.2024.112760 doi: 10.1016/j.jcp.2024.112760
[25]	L. D. McClenny, U. M. Braga-Neto, Self-adaptive physics-informed neural networks, J. Comput. Phys., 474 (2023), 111722. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jcp.2022.111722 doi: 10.1016/j.jcp.2022.111722
[26]	A. Kopaniaáková, H. Kothari, G. E. Karniadakis, R. Krause, Enhancing training of physics-informed neural networks using domain decomposition-based preconditioning strategies, SIAM J. Sci. Comput., 46 (2024), S46–S67. https://doi.org/10.1137/23M1583375 doi: 10.1137/23M1583375
[27]	R. Qiu, R. Huang, Y. Xiao, J. Wang, Z. Zhang, J. Yue, et al., Physics-informed neural networks for phase-field method in two-phase flow, Phys. Fluids, 34 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1063/5.0091063
[28]	Y. Ghaffari Motlagh, P. K. Jimack, R. de Borst, Deep learning phase-field model for brittle fractures, Int. J. Numer. Methods Eng., 124, (2023), 620–638. https://doi.org/10.1002/nme.7135 doi: 10.1002/nme.7135
[29]	W. Li, M. Z. Bazant, J. Zhu, Phase-Field DeepONet: Physics-informed deep operator neural network for fast simulations of pattern formation governed by gradient flows of free-energy functionals, Comput. Meth. Appl. Mech. Eng., 416 (2023), 116299. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cma.2023.116299 doi: 10.1016/j.cma.2023.116299
[30]	S. Ham, J. Kim, Stability analysis for a maximum principle preserving explicit scheme of the Allen–Cahn equation, Math. Comput. Simul., 207 (2023), 453–465. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matcom.2023.01.016 doi: 10.1016/j.matcom.2023.01.016
[31]	M. Penwarden, A. D. Jagtap, S. Zhe, G. E. Karniadakis, R. M. Kirby, A unified scalable framework for causal sweeping strategies for Physics-Informed Neural Networks (PINNs) and their temporal decompositions, J. Comput. Phys., 493 (2023), 112464. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jcp.2023.112464 doi: 10.1016/j.jcp.2023.112464
[32]	S. Kim, J. Kim, Automatic binary data classification using a modified Allen–Cahn equation, Int. J. Pattern Recognit. Artif. Intell., 35 (2021), 2150013. https://doi.org/10.1142/S0218001421500130 doi: 10.1142/S0218001421500130
[33]	Y. Li, J. Shin, Y. Choi, J. Kim, Three-dimensional volume reconstruction from slice data using phase-field models, Comput. Vis. Image Underst., 137 (2015), 115–124. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cviu.2015.02.001 doi: 10.1016/j.cviu.2015.02.001

This article has been cited by:

1.	Selasi Kwaku Ocloo, Lewis Brew, Suleman Nasiru, Benjamin Odoi, Jewgeni Dshalalow, Harmonic Mixture Fréchet Distribution: Properties and Applications to Lifetime Data, 2022, 2022, 1687-0425, 1, 10.1155/2022/6460362
2.	Xueyu Wu, Zubair Ahmad, Eslam Hussam, Marwan H. Alhelali, Ramy Aldallal, Muqrin A. Almuqrin, Fathy H. Riad, A new Cosine-Weibull model: Distributional properties with applications to basketball and medical sectors, 2023, 66, 11100168, 751, 10.1016/j.aej.2022.10.068
3.	Abdul Ghaniyyu Abubakari, Chin-Chia Wu, Actuarial Measures, Regression, and Applications of Exponentiated Fréchet Loss Distribution, 2022, 2022, 1687-0425, 1, 10.1155/2022/3155188
4.	Adam Braima S. Mastor, Oscar Ngesa, Joseph Mung’atu, Nada M. Alfaer, Ahmed Z. Afify, M. De Aguiar, The Extended Exponential Weibull Distribution: Properties, Inference, and Applications to Real-Life Data, 2022, 2022, 1099-0526, 1, 10.1155/2022/4068842
5.	Otieno Kevin Okumu, Omondi Joseph Ouno, Anthony Nyutu Karanjah, Samuel Nganga Muthiga, Three-parameters Gumbel Distribution: Formulation and Parameter Estimation, 2024, 10, 2472-3509, 25, 10.11648/j.ijsd.20241002.12
6.	Fatimah E. Almuhayfith, Talha Arslan, Hassan S. Bakouch, Aminh M. Alnaghmosh, A versatile model for lifetime of a component under stress, 2023, 13, 2045-2322, 10.1038/s41598-023-47313-3
7.	Hassan M. Aljohani, The single and double inverse Pareto–Burr XII distribution: Properties, estimation methods, and real-life data applications, 2024, 14, 2158-3226, 10.1063/5.0203919
8.	M. G. M. Ghazal, Yusra A. Tashkandy, Oluwafemi Samson Balogun, M. E. Bakr, Exponentiated extended extreme value distribution: Properties, estimation, and applications in applied fields, 2024, 9, 2473-6988, 17634, 10.3934/math.2024857
9.	Ahmed Z. Afify, Ekramy A. Hussein, Hazem Al-Mofleh, Rehab Alsultan, Hassan M. Aljohani, Nian-Sheng Tang, The Flexible Fréchet Distribution: Properties, Inference, and Medical Applications, 2024, 2024, 2314-4629, 10.1155/jom/2600560
10.	Hatem Semary, Ahmad Abubakar Suleiman, Aliyu Ismail Ishaq, Jamilu Yunusa Falgore, Umar Kabir Abdullahi, Hanita Daud, Mohamed A. Abd Elgawad, Mohammad Elgarhy, A new modified Sine-Weibull distribution for modeling medical data with dynamic structures, 2025, 18, 16878507, 101427, 10.1016/j.jrras.2025.101427
11.	Dawlah Alsulami, A new extension of the Rayleigh distribution: Properties, different methods of estimation, and an application to medical data, 2025, 10, 2473-6988, 7636, 10.3934/math.2025350

Reader Comments

Your name:*

Email:*
© 2025 the Author(s), licensee AIMS Press. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0)